Are Malaysian journalism schools adequately preparing graduates for the newsroom?

Question

Accepted Answer

Malaysian journalism schools are not adequately preparing graduates for the newsroom due to a narrow curriculum.

Malaysian journalism schools often limit their curriculum to media-related fields like advertising, broadcasting, and public relations, failing to equip graduates with the broader contextual understanding sought by newsroom editors. While local institutions focus on vocational skills such as news writing and media technology, prestigious international counterparts encourage engagement with subjects outside the immediate field, such as philosophy and literature, to foster deeper reporting capabilities. This discrepancy results in graduates who may possess technical skills but lack the diverse knowledge base that editors find valuable for in-depth storytelling.
Limited Curriculum Scope

The curricula in Malaysian journalism schools predominantly revolve around vocational skills within the media industry, including advertising, broadcasting, and public relations. This confined approach restricts graduates' learning to their immediate field, with limited opportunities for interdisciplinary exploration unless pursued independently. Such a narrow focus can hinder the development of a comprehensive understanding of the world, which is crucial for effective journalism.
Editor Preferences for Diverse Backgrounds

Newsroom editors frequently express a preference for candidates from varied academic backgrounds, such as doctors, artists, engineers, teachers, or economists, over those with journalism degrees. This preference stems from the belief that individuals with diverse life experiences and specialised knowledge bring greater depth, character, and understanding to their reporting. The varied perspectives offered by non-journalism graduates are seen as more beneficial for contextualising stories than the vocational skills typically taught in local journalism programmes.
Vocational Focus vs. Contextual Understanding

Local journalism schools tend to emphasise practical, vocational skills like news writing, media technology, and audiovisual mastery. While these technical proficiencies are important, they are often insufficient on their own. The core of journalism lies in understanding the context and implications of events, a skill that is not adequately developed when education remains solely within the confines of media-related disciplines.
International Educational Models

In contrast, leading journalism schools in countries like the United States offer a broader educational experience. These institutions often incorporate courses from other disciplines, such as philosophy and English literature, encouraging students to engage with subjects that enhance critical thinking and provide a wider worldview. This approach aims to produce graduates who not only know how to report but also possess a deeper understanding of the subject matter, a quality that is less emphasized in the current Malaysian journalism education landscape.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Are Malaysian journalism schools adequately preparing graduates for the newsroom?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends