Are parliamentary select committees truly functioning effectively?

Question

Accepted Answer

Parliamentary Select Committees Face Scrutiny Over Transparency and Effectiveness

Doubts have been raised regarding the effective functioning of parliamentary select committees in Malaysia, primarily due to a lack of transparency in their operations. These committees, established by Pakatan Harapan, currently conduct their meetings behind closed doors with no provision for live broadcasts or public Hansard records. This opacity contrasts with the public accessibility of parliamentary sittings and has led to calls for greater openness, allowing citizens to observe proceedings similar to how they can witness debates in both the Dewan Rakyat and Dewan Negara.
Lack of Public Access to Committee Proceedings

A significant concern highlighted is the absence of public access to the deliberations of parliamentary select committees. Unlike the live broadcasts and published records available for parliamentary sessions, the meetings of these committees are conducted privately. This lack of a public record, such as a Hansard, means that the public and even other parliamentarians cannot easily ascertain the discussions and decisions made within these crucial bodies, thereby limiting accountability.
International Benchmarks for Select Committee Operations

In many established parliamentary democracies, select committees operate with a high degree of transparency. It is common practice for their proceedings to be broadcast live and for detailed minutes or Hansard records to be made publicly available. These practices allow for greater scrutiny of their work, facilitate public engagement with the legislative process, and ensure that committee members are accountable for their contributions and votes, mirroring the openness expected in the main parliamentary chambers.
Calls for Enhanced Transparency and Public Observation

There is a growing sentiment that the public should be afforded the opportunity to observe the meetings of key committees, such as the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) and other Special Select Committees. This suggestion aligns with the principle that parliamentary functions should be as open as possible, enabling citizens to witness firsthand how important legislative oversight and policy scrutiny are conducted. Granting public access would foster a greater sense of trust and allow for more informed public discourse on the work of these committees.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Are parliamentary select committees truly functioning effectively?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends