Are Perak education phones truly usable for online learning?

Question

Accepted Answer

Low-Specification Smartphones Distributed by Perak Government Raise Concerns Over Online Learning Suitability

Amanah Youth has raised significant concerns regarding the usability of 20,000 smartphones distributed by the Perak state government to students under the Tuisyen Cikgu Saarani (TCS) programme. The organisation claims these devices are inadequately equipped for online learning, possessing only the most basic functionalities and falling far short of contemporary technological standards. While the state government asserts the low specifications were a deliberate measure to deter gaming, critics argue this approach reflects an outdated mindset that is out of step with the demands of modern education.
Critiques of Device Specifications

The smartphones in question are reportedly equipped with a MediaTek 1.3GHz processor, 1GB of RAM, and 8GB of internal storage. Amanah Youth has strongly criticised these specifications, likening the underlying technological thinking to the era of the Nokia 3310, a device launched in 2000. This comparison highlights the perceived obsolescence of the hardware in a landscape where global technology is rapidly advancing towards 5G capabilities. The organisation argues that such low specifications render the devices largely unsuitable for the complex demands of current educational software and online platforms.
State Government's Rationale

Perak's executive council member responsible for education, Ahmad Saidi Mohammad Daud, has stated that the intentionally low specifications of the distributed smartphones were a strategic decision. The primary objective, according to the government, was to prevent students from diverting their attention from educational use to mobile gaming. This rationale suggests a paternalistic approach to device distribution, aiming to control student behaviour rather than solely focusing on educational enablement. The government's stance implies a belief that higher-spec devices would inevitably lead to misuse, thus compromising the educational goals of the programme.
Perceived Disconnect with Modern Educational Needs

Amanah Youth contends that the state government's approach demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of the essential role smart devices play in contemporary education. In an era where home-based learning has become increasingly prevalent, these devices are no longer considered a luxury but a necessity for accessing educational resources and participating in online classes. The organisation's critique suggests a significant gap between the technological provisions being made and the actual requirements for effective digital learning, potentially hindering students' academic progress.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Are Perak education phones truly usable for online learning?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends