Are the 1MDB board minutes Najib seeks relevant to his RM2.27b charges?

Question

Accepted Answer

The 1MDB Board Meeting Minutes Sought by Najib Are Deemed Irrelevant to His Charges

The 1MDB board meeting minutes from 2018 to 2024 are considered irrelevant to the charges of RM2.27 billion in 1MDB funds faced by former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak. Najib's legal team had sought these minutes through subpoenas served on two 1MDB company secretaries, aiming to challenge prosecution witnesses' credibility and understand why certain lawsuits were dropped. However, 1MDB's lawyer, Datuk Lim Chee Wee, argued that the requested documents pertain to post-2018 asset recovery efforts and general administrative matters, which fall outside the scope of the charges against Najib, as these predominantly relate to events prior to 2018.
Minutes Pertain to Post-2018 Asset Recovery Efforts

The core of 1MDB's objection lies in the timeframe and content of the minutes Najib is requesting. The charges against Najib are linked to transactions and events that occurred before 2018. In contrast, the 1MDB board meetings from 2018 onwards have focused on the company's strategies and actions to recover its assets, as well as routine administrative functions. 1MDB's legal counsel argued that these later minutes do not contain information pertinent to the specific allegations Najib is currently defending against in court.
Legal Privileges Protect the Minutes

Furthermore, 1MDB asserted that the post-2018 board meeting minutes are protected by litigation privilege and legal professional privilege. These privileges are standard in legal proceedings and are intended to shield confidential communications, including legal advice received by the company and discussions involving government agencies concerning asset recovery. The minutes in question reportedly include legal advice on initiating and withdrawing lawsuits, as well as government-to-government communications related to civil forfeiture actions.
Bid Characterised as a "Fishing Expedition"

1MDB's lawyer explicitly described Najib's attempt to obtain these minutes as a "fishing expedition." This legal term refers to a request for discovery of evidence that is based on mere speculation rather than on a reasonable belief that such evidence exists. The company argued that Najib is seeking access to information about its litigation strategy against him and his family members, an attempt that amounts to an abuse of the court process, especially given that 1MDB has filed separate lawsuits against Najib and his relatives, with the same legal team representing Najib in both the trial and these civil suits.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Are the 1MDB board minutes Najib seeks relevant to his RM2.27b charges?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends