Can 19ha mining projects legally bypass EIA requirements?

Question

Accepted Answer

19ha Mining Projects Can Legally Bypass EIA Requirements Through a Specific Loophole

Yes, 19-hectare mining projects can legally bypass environmental impact assessment (EIA) requirements in certain circumstances by exploiting a regulatory loophole. This loophole involves intentionally sizing projects just below the 20-hectare threshold that mandates an EIA. This situation has arisen in Langkawi's Gunung Raya Forest Reserve, where a 19-hectare sand mining project was approved by the Kedah government in May 2021, despite the area being previously identified as a Sensitive Environmental Area Class 1. A further 19-hectare plot is also under consideration for sand mining adjacent to the initial site.
Regulatory Threshold Allows Evasion of EIA

The primary mechanism enabling these projects to bypass EIA scrutiny is the specific land area threshold set by regulations. Projects exceeding 20 hectares are legally required to undergo an EIA process and submit a report to the Department of Environment (DOE) for approval. However, by limiting the project size to 19 hectares, developers can circumvent this mandatory environmental review. This practice has been acknowledged by state DOE officials, who have indicated their inability to intervene due to the existence of this loophole.
Potential Environmental Impacts Remain Despite Lack of EIA

Despite the legal bypass of EIA requirements, these sand mining operations pose significant environmental risks. State officials have conceded that the approved mining projects could potentially impact the water catchment area supplying the Padang Saga treatment plant, a critical resource for Langkawi. Furthermore, two-thirds of the island's water supply is already dependent on water piped from mainland Malaysia, making any threat to local water sources particularly concerning. The potential for these developments to jeopardise Langkawi's Unesco Global Geopark status, a designation held since 2007, is also a significant worry for conservationists.
Lack of Government Action to Close the Loophole

There appears to be a lack of immediate action from federal authorities to address this regulatory gap. When questioned about potential plans to close this EIA loophole, both the Environment and Water Minister Datuk Seri Tuan Ibrahim Tuan Man and the DOE did not provide a response. This inaction leaves the door open for similar projects to proceed without comprehensive environmental assessments, raising concerns about the long-term sustainability of development in ecologically sensitive areas.
Project Details and Developer Statements

The 19-hectare sand mining project in the Gunung Raya Forest Reserve is a joint venture involving Sukmas Dimensi, a private construction firm, and Yiked, a subsidiary of the state-controlled Kedah Islamic Foundation. Sukmas Dimensi has stated that work is anticipated to commence early next year and that efforts will be focused on accessing mining areas in segments of approximately 5 hectares at a time, asserting that no trees have been disturbed yet. Separately, Kedah Cement, a subsidiary of YTL, was approached by Sukmas Dimensi on behalf of Yiked to purchase 30-year mining rights for a 40-hectare area in Gunung Raya for RM6 million, despite only 19 hectares being officially approved.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Can 19ha mining projects legally bypass EIA requirements?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends