Can abandoned children be protected from statelessness by Section 19B?

Question

Accepted Answer

Section 19B of Malaysia's Federal Constitution offers protection against statelessness for abandoned "new born" children, but its application is contingent on the child's age at the time of discovery.

Section 19B of the Federal Constitution provides a presumption of Malaysian citizenship for abandoned children, aiming to prevent statelessness. This provision states that any "new born child found exposed in any place" is presumed to have been born to a mother who is a permanent resident, with the discovery date serving as the child's birth date. The Court of Appeal has acknowledged the crucial role of Section 19B in safeguarding against statelessness for such vulnerable children.
The "New Born Child" Qualification is a Limiting Factor

While Section 19B has a protective purpose, the Court of Appeal has clarified that it does not extend to all abandoned children. The key determining factor is whether the child can be classified as "new born" at the time they were found. In a specific case, a woman identified as G, who was found abandoned at approximately one to one and a half years old, was deemed not to be a "new born child" by the court. Consequently, Section 19B was not applied to her situation.
Age Threshold for "New Born" Remains Undefined but Fact-Dependent

The Court of Appeal has not established a precise medical definition for "new born child" within the context of Section 19B. Instead, the court's determination relies on the specific facts of each case. For instance, a child aged one or one and a half years old was considered too old to be described as "new born" under this section. The court views the term "new born child" as a "word of limitation," indicating that the age of the abandoned child is a critical element in assessing eligibility for protection under Section 19B.
Recent Rulings Show Varied Application Based on Age

In contrast to the case of G, another abandoned child, M, who was found a few days after birth, was determined by the Court of Appeal to be an abandoned "new born child" and thus entitled to Malaysian citizenship by operation of law under Section 19B. This ruling highlights the sensitivity of the age factor. However, the government has since filed an appeal against the decision in M's case, indicating ongoing legal scrutiny of the interpretation and application of Section 19B.
Alternative Avenues for Citizenship May Exist

The Court of Appeal has suggested that abandoned children who do not qualify for citizenship under Section 19B, due to not meeting the "new born" criterion, may still have recourse. These children could potentially apply for citizenship through naturalisation under Article 19 of the Federal Constitution, provided they meet the stipulated requirements and are deemed eligible by the federal government.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Can abandoned children be protected from statelessness by Section 19B?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends