Can Malaysia extradite Sirul Azhar for his death sentence?

Question

Accepted Answer

Malaysia's Extradition Options for Sirul Azhar Umar Depend on Death Penalty Review

Malaysia's ability to extradite Sirul Azhar Umar, who was recently released from immigration detention in Australia, is contingent upon him seeking a review of his death sentence and having it commuted. This requirement stems from the principle of dual criminality, a fundamental aspect of extradition agreements between Malaysia and Australia. Without this legal prerequisite, the existing extradition framework cannot be invoked to bring him back to face his conviction for the murder of Mongolian national Altantuya Shaariibuu.
Dual Criminality and Extradition Agreements

The principle of dual criminality dictates that an act must be considered a criminal offence in both the requesting and the requested country for extradition to proceed. In Sirul Azhar's case, while murder is a crime in both Malaysia and Australia, the application of the death penalty complicates matters. Australia has abolished capital punishment, and its laws generally prohibit the extradition of individuals to countries where they may face execution. Therefore, for Malaysia to successfully request Sirul Azhar's extradition, the death sentence would need to be converted to a lesser penalty, such as life imprisonment, to align with Australian legal principles.
The Process of Sentence Review and Commutation

For Sirul Azhar to be extradited to face his original conviction, he would need to initiate a legal process in Malaysia to have his death sentence reviewed and commuted. This would typically involve applying to the relevant Malaysian authorities, such as the Pardons Board, to have the sentence reconsidered. If the sentence is commuted, it means it is reduced or altered, in this context, from a death sentence to imprisonment. This legal adjustment is crucial as it would satisfy the dual criminality requirement, enabling Malaysia to formally request his extradition from Australia under their mutual legal assistance treaties.
Malaysian Authorities' Stance and Next Steps

The Malaysian Home Minister, Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail, has explicitly stated that extradition is only possible if Sirul Azhar's death penalty is reviewed and commuted. Following his release from detention in Sydney on November 11, after nine years of being held since 2015, Malaysian police have indicated they will consult with key parties, including the Attorney-General and the courts. This consultation aims to explore the feasibility of seeking Sirul Azhar's repatriation, but it remains clear that any such action is bound by the legal constraints imposed by the dual criminality principle and Australia's stance on capital punishment.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Can Malaysia extradite Sirul Azhar for his death sentence?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends