Can PAS remain a trusted Pakatan Rakyat ally with Hadi as president?

Question

Accepted Answer

PAS's Credibility Questioned Amidst Hudud Push Under Hadi's Leadership

The credibility of PAS as a trusted ally within Pakatan Rakyat (PR) and among Malaysians is under significant doubt as long as Datuk Seri Hadi Awang remains its president. This concern stems from accusations that Hadi has betrayed the seven-year pact by misrepresenting its terms to advance Kelantan's hudud amendment proposals. Critics argue that Hadi's actions demonstrate dishonesty and deceit, leading to the conclusion that PAS, under his leadership, cannot be reliably trusted by its coalition partners or the wider Malaysian public.
Disagreement on Hudud Policy Within Pakatan Rakyat

DAP, a key component of Pakatan Rakyat, has consistently expressed its opposition to the implementation of hudud law since the coalition's formation after the 2008 general elections. This fundamental disagreement was formally acknowledged in a statement signed in September 2011, which established an "agree to disagree" understanding on the hudud issue. This arrangement explicitly signifies that hudud is not a policy of the entire coalition, underscoring the contentious nature of PAS's unilateral moves.
Kelantan's State-Level Hudud Amendments

The PAS-led state government of Kelantan recently passed crucial amendments to its Shariah Criminal Code II 1993. These legislative changes are intended to pave the way for the eventual implementation of hudud punishments within the state. Notably, all twelve Umno state lawmakers in Kelantan voted in favour of these amendments, a move that has drawn attention given Umno's national stance on the issue.
PAS's Federal Ambitions and Parliamentary Challenge

PAS harbours ambitions to implement hudud at the federal level and has indicated plans to table a private member's Bill in Parliament. This proposed legislation aims to grant Kelantan the legal framework necessary to enact hudud punishments, which can include penalties such as amputation for crimes like theft. Although Hadi has formally notified Parliament of the intended Bill, its inclusion in the current session's order paper remains uncertain due to scheduling constraints. The success of such a Bill would necessitate support from Muslim Members of Parliament from other parties, as PAS's own contingent of 21 MPs is insufficient to secure a majority on its own.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Can PAS remain a trusted Pakatan Rakyat ally with Hadi as president?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends