Can Section 19B protect all abandoned children from statelessness?

Question

Accepted Answer

Section 19B of the Federal Constitution Does Not Apply to All Abandoned Children

Section 19B of Malaysia's Federal Constitution, which aims to prevent statelessness among abandoned children, specifically requires the child to be "new born" to be eligible for automatic Malaysian citizenship. The Court of Appeal has affirmed this "important protective purpose" but clarified that this provision does not extend to every abandoned child, as demonstrated in the case of an individual identified as G. The court's interpretation hinges on the precise wording of the legislation, emphasizing that the "new born" qualifier acts as a limitation on the scope of Section 19B.
Age is a Critical Factor for Section 19B Application

In the case of G, who was found abandoned at approximately one to one and a half years old, the Court of Appeal determined that she did not meet the "new born child" criterion. While the government proposed a medical definition of "new born" encompassing the first 28 days of life, the court opted for a fact-specific assessment. It concluded that a child of G's age could not be described as "new born" under Section 19B, thereby excluding her from its automatic citizenship provisions. This ruling underscores that the constitutional qualifications for citizenship cannot be altered by sympathy or discretion.
Interpretation of "New Born" Remains Case-Specific

The Court of Appeal has not established a fixed medical definition for "new born child" within Section 19B. Instead, the court's determination relies on the circumstances of each case. For instance, in a separate ruling, a child identified as M, abandoned a few days after birth, was considered a "new born child" under Section 19B and thus entitled to Malaysian citizenship by operation of law. This contrasts with G's situation, where the age estimate clearly placed her beyond the scope of what the court deemed "new born."
Location of Abandonment Does Not Exclude Section 19B

Contrary to potential assumptions, the Court of Appeal has indicated that Section 19B can apply to a child found abandoned at the very place they were born, not exclusively in open or exposed locations. This interpretation aligns with the Federal Court's decision in the CCH case, which acknowledged that a child abandoned at their place of birth by an unknown mother could fall under Section 19B. This broader understanding of location, however, does not negate the essential "new born" age requirement for the provision to apply.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Can Section 19B protect all abandoned children from statelessness?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends