Did demonetisation achieve its goal of flushing out black money?

Question

Accepted Answer

Demonetisation's Impact on Flushing Out Black Money Remains Contested

Data from India's central bank, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), indicates that nearly all of the high-value currency notes withdrawn from circulation in 2016 subsequently returned to the banking system. This outcome suggests that the primary objective of flushing out undeclared wealth, commonly referred to as 'black money,' may not have been fully realised. However, the government maintains that the policy successfully increased tax compliance and integrated more funds into the formal financial system.
Near-Total Return of Withdrawn Notes

In November 2016, Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government invalidated 500 and 1,000 rupee notes, with the stated aim of eradicating unaccounted cash, counterfeit currency, and the financing of militant activities. The Reserve Bank of India's data revealed that out of the 15.41 trillion rupees worth of these notes in circulation before the ban, approximately 15.30 trillion rupees had been returned to banks by June 2017. This near-complete return of currency implies that a significant portion of the 'black money' was not destroyed or lost as intended but was instead deposited back into the formal banking channels.
Government Claims of Increased Tax Compliance

Despite the high return rate of currency, the government asserts that the demonetisation policy achieved success by transforming India into a more tax-compliant society. Finance Minister Arun Jaitley highlighted a substantial increase in income tax returns filed, with the number nearly doubling to around 69 million in the 2017/18 fiscal year compared to the 2013/14 period. He further noted that the deposit of previously anonymous cash into banks allowed for the identification of 1.8 million depositors for further inquiry, many of whom faced penalties, suggesting a deterrent effect on illicit wealth accumulation.
Opposition's Critique and Economic Concerns

The opposition Congress party has strongly criticised the demonetisation move, citing the RBI data as proof of its failure to achieve its core objectives. They argue that the policy inflicted significant damage on India's cash-dependent economy, leading to an estimated loss of 1.5 million jobs and a 1.5 percentage point reduction in economic growth. Furthermore, the party pointed to the substantial expenditure of approximately 80 billion rupees on printing new currency notes as an unproductive cost associated with the policy.
Prime Minister's Stated Successes

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has defended the demonetisation policy by emphasizing its role in bringing all currency into the formal banking system. He stated that the intention was to formalise the financial landscape, and this objective was successfully met. While the policy's impact on 'black money' is debated due to the high return rate of notes, the government's perspective focuses on the broader integration of funds and the subsequent increase in tax scrutiny and compliance as key achievements.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Did demonetisation achieve its goal of flushing out black money?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends