Did IBM overvalue its microelectronics division before sale?

Question

Accepted Answer

The Supreme Court Will Hear a Case Questioning the Valuation of IBM's Microelectronics Division Before its Sale

The US Supreme Court has agreed to review a case that questions whether IBM's retirement fund managers can be sued for allegedly failing to disclose that the company's microelectronics division was overvalued. Participants in the IBM retirement plan claim that in 2013, the microelectronics division was experiencing losses, despite IBM stating its value at US$2 billion at that time. The plaintiffs allege that the Retirement Plans Committee of IBM, which managed the fund, was aware or should have been aware of this overvaluation.
Allegations of Overvaluation and Subsequent Sale

The core of the dispute centres on the valuation of IBM's microelectronics business prior to its sale. Participants in the company's retirement plan have stated that in 2013, this division was incurring losses, contradicting IBM's assertion of a US$2 billion valuation. The plaintiffs further contend that the Retirement Plans Committee, which includes senior IBM executives, knew or should have known about the inflated value of the business.
Significant Financial Implications of the Sale

The situation came to a head when IBM sold the microelectronics business the following year at what is described as a substantial loss. This sale involved IBM paying GlobalFoundries Inc US$1.5 billion to take over the money-losing unit. Following the transaction, IBM announced a US$2.4 billion write-down on the total asset value, in addition to US$800 million in other unspecified costs, indicating a significant disparity between the reported valuation and the eventual sale outcome.
Legal Proceedings and Appeal to the Supreme Court

The plaintiffs initiated legal action against the committee and its members in 2015. After an initial dismissal by a federal judge, the litigation was revived by the New York-based 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals last year. This appellate ruling prompted the retirement plan committee to appeal to the Supreme Court, leading to the current review of the case. The Supreme Court's decision will determine whether these claims can proceed to trial.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Did IBM overvalue its microelectronics division before sale?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends