Did the EC ignore parliamentary confirmation about the camp?

Question

Accepted Answer

Election Commission Challenged Over Parliamentary Confirmation of Segamat Camp Status

The Election Commission (EC) is facing a legal challenge where a group of 48 voters from Segamat allege that the EC disregarded parliamentary confirmation regarding the incomplete status of an army camp. The voters contend that this alleged oversight constitutes an "exceptional circumstance" justifying their lawsuit, despite the EC's argument that internal appeals should have been exhausted first. The core of the dispute centres on the registration of 949 voters associated with the Segamat army camp, which the challengers claim was not yet completed at the time of registration.
Voters Allege Disregard for Deputy Defence Minister's Statement

The 48 Segamat voters argue that their right to be heard was not respected, citing the parliamentary Hansard of November 27, 2017. In this record, Deputy Defence Minister Datuk Seri Mohd Johari Baharum reportedly confirmed that the Segamat army camp was not completed. The voters' legal representatives assert that this parliamentary confirmation was raised during objections to the voter registration but was subsequently ignored by the EC's electoral registrar.
EC Argues for Exhaustion of Internal Appeal Mechanisms

The Election Commission has raised a preliminary objection to the lawsuit, asserting that the 48 voters should have first pursued all available internal appeal avenues within the EC. According to the EC's Johor electoral registrar, Shafie Taib, objections against the inclusion of the 949 personnel and their spouses were dismissed. The EC points to Regulation 20 of the Elections (Registration of Electors) Regulations 2002, which allows objectors to appeal a registrar's decision to an adjudicating officer, suggesting this route should have been fully explored.
Court Granted Interim Stay on Voter Certification

In response to the voters' concerns, the High Court granted an interim stay on the certification of the 949 names. This legal measure prevents the formal confirmation of these individuals as voters pending the outcome of the lawsuit. The affidavit supporting the voters' case also noted a notice board at the Segamat Camp, which indicated an expected completion date of April 16, 2018, further substantiating their claim that the camp was not finished when voter registration occurred.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Did the EC ignore parliamentary confirmation about the camp?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends