How do illiteracy and lack of education contribute to statelessness in Malaysia?

Question

Accepted Answer

Illiteracy and Lack of Education as Factors in Statelessness

Illiteracy and a general lack of education have significantly contributed to individuals remaining stateless in Malaysia, particularly affecting those from estate or plantation backgrounds. The challenges faced by individuals like Velmurugan highlight how a lack of understanding of bureaucratic processes and legal requirements can impede birth registration and subsequent citizenship claims. This situation is often exacerbated by the historical context of birth registration practices in Malaysia, where formal documentation was not always prioritised for communities living in more isolated or rural settings.

The case of Velmurugan and his mother, Balamah, illustrates these complexities. Velmurugan’s grandmother, though born in Perak, had an undetermined citizenship status, a situation that cascaded through generations. His mother, Balamah, born pre-Merdeka in Kuala Lumpur, and Velmurugan himself, born in 1987 on a plantation in Tanjung Malim, both lacked birth certificates. Their births were only registered with the National Registration Department (NRD) much later, in 2011 for Balamah and 2019 for Velmurugan. This delay was attributed to Balamah’s lack of awareness regarding the necessity of registering births due to her illiteracy. Velmurugan’s own lack of schooling meant he was also unfamiliar with these procedures.

The NRD's classification of Balamah’s citizenship status as "not determined yet" stemmed from inconsistencies in witness testimonies regarding her birthplace and the number of siblings. Despite her siblings born pre-Merdeka being registered as Malaysians and DNA tests confirming her biological relation to them, the ambiguities created hurdles. This underscores how a lack of formal education can impact the ability to provide consistent or officially recognised evidence required for citizenship applications. In Malaysia, for individuals born before Merdeka Day, claiming citizenship often involves fulfilling specific conditions and providing documentation that may be difficult to procure for those with limited educational backgrounds or who lived in areas where formal record-keeping was less common.

The legal implications are substantial. The High Court's ruling in Velmurugan's case emphasised that he first needed to establish his mother's Malaysian status. If he failed to prove his mother was Malaysian, he would, by extension, be considered a non-citizen, mirroring his mother's status. This dependency on proving lineage and parental citizenship, especially for individuals whose parents or grandparents might have had undetermined statuses due to historical registration gaps, creates a significant barrier. The Federal Constitution's provisions, such as Article 16 for those born in Malaysia before Merdeka Day, offer a pathway to registration, but these processes require adherence to legal formalities and the presentation of evidence that can be challenging for those with limited literacy and formal education.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

How do illiteracy and lack of education contribute to statelessness in Malaysia?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends