How do Singapore and Indonesia compare regarding death penalty use?

Question

Accepted Answer

Singapore Executed Significantly More Convicts Than Indonesia Between 1999 and 2005

During the period of 1999 to 2005, Singapore implemented capital punishment at a rate nearly 15 times higher than Indonesia. This stark difference in execution numbers between the two nations has been used to challenge the assertion that the death penalty acts as a deterrent against drug trafficking.
Execution Rates and Drug Trafficking

Analysis comparing Singapore and Indonesia between 1999 and 2005 revealed that Singapore, despite its smaller population, executed a substantially greater number of individuals. Specifically, Singapore carried out almost 15 times more executions than Indonesia over this seven-year span.
Drug Prices and Availability

The argument against the deterrent effect of capital punishment posits that if it were effective, drug trafficking would be less prevalent and drug prices would be higher in countries with more stringent application of the death penalty. However, data from 2003 to 2006 indicated that cocaine and heroin prices were notably higher in Indonesia than in Singapore. Furthermore, drugs were generally more widely available in Singapore during the same period, suggesting no clear correlation between higher execution rates and reduced drug activity.
Malaysian Context on Drug Availability

Further evidence challenging the deterrent effect of capital punishment comes from Malaysia. A report from the International Narcotics Control Board in 2004 suggested an increase in the availability of heroin in Malaysia, despite over 200 executions having taken place in the country since 1975. This observation points to rising demand as a potential driver for drug availability, rather than the perceived impact of capital punishment on traffickers.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

How do Singapore and Indonesia compare regarding death penalty use?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends