How does Brunei reconcile sharia law with human rights obligations?

Question

Accepted Answer

Brunei's Stance on Sharia Law and Human Rights Obligations

Brunei asserts that its Syariah penal code does not criminalise individuals based on their sexual orientation or beliefs, claiming that all citizens, irrespective of sexual orientation, live without discrimination in their private lives. However, this position is presented alongside a penal code that includes severe punishments, such as death by stoning for consensual same-sex relations, which has drawn significant international criticism for potentially contravening human rights commitments.
Distinction Between Status and Act

The deputy foreign minister of Brunei, Dato Erywan Mohn Yusof, stated that the Syariah penal code order does not criminalise a person's status based on sexual orientation or belief. He further elaborated that individuals in Brunei, regardless of their sexual orientation, can pursue their activities in their private space without facing discrimination. This distinction aims to separate the prohibition of an act from the criminalisation of an individual's identity or status.
Prohibition of Acts for Societal Protection

While asserting that personal choices are not criminalised, Brunei does prohibit "the act" of gay sex. This prohibition, according to the deputy foreign minister, is framed as necessary for protecting the nation's religion, tradition, social fabric, and values. This justification is offered in response to international concerns that the full implementation of sharia law, which fully came into force in April and includes punishments like amputation for theft, could conflict with Brunei's international human rights obligations.
International Concerns and Calls for Reform

The implementation of Brunei's sharia code has faced a global backlash, with diplomats from countries including Canada, various European and Latin American states, and the United States urging Brunei to enact reforms. These nations have expressed concern that the full enforcement of sharia law could contravene international human rights obligations and commitments. Specific calls have been made for the decriminalisation of consensual same-sex sexual activity, with some diplomats warning of increasingly inhumane treatment within the country.
Sultan's Moratorium on Death Penalty Measures

In response to the widespread criticism, the Sultan of Brunei announced that the death penalty measures within the sharia code would not be enforced. This announcement has provided some relief to gay Bruneians, who had expressed concern over the severity of the law. Despite this moratorium, the country continues to face scrutiny regarding its human rights record and the potential for discrimination against LGBT individuals, even with laws not explicitly criminalising their status.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

How does Brunei reconcile sharia law with human rights obligations?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends