How does Clause 18 limit Dewan Rakyat’s vetting powers?

Question

Accepted Answer

Clause 18 Limits Parliamentary Vetting to Informing and Commenting, Lacking Genuine Oversight

Clause 18 of the proposed constitutional amendment concerning the separation of the Attorney General and Public Prosecutor roles restricts the Dewan Rakyat's involvement to merely being informed of nominated names and offering comments. Lawmakers argue this provision is perfunctory and does not provide the meaningful oversight necessary for such a significant appointment. They advocate for a more robust, bipartisan parliamentary vetting process that includes open and transparent hearings to allow for rigorous examination of nominees on behalf of the public.
Informing Parliament and Allowing Comments

The current wording of Clause 18 stipulates that the Judicial and Legal Service Commission is only required to inform Parliament about individuals nominated for the top prosecutorial post. This provision allows members of the Dewan Rakyat to provide comments on these nominations. However, this is presented as the extent of parliamentary engagement under this clause.
Perfunctory Mechanism Devoid of Genuine Oversight

Several PKR lawmakers have voiced strong objections to this limited mechanism, with Subang MP Wong Chen labelling it "perfunctory and devoid of genuine oversight." The concern is that this process does not empower Parliament to conduct a thorough assessment of the nominees' suitability for the crucial role of Public Prosecutor.
Call for Bipartisan Vetting and Transparent Hearings

In response to the perceived shortcomings of Clause 18, lawmakers are proposing an alternative. They are calling for a comprehensive bipartisan parliamentary vetting process. This would involve open and transparent hearings where Parliament, acting in representation of the public, could rigorously scrutinise and examine each nominee before any final decision is made.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

How does Clause 18 limit Dewan Rakyat’s vetting powers?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends