How does past government loyalty affect current civil service reform?

Question

Accepted Answer

Past Loyalty's Influence on Current Civil Service Reform

The legacy of past government loyalty significantly impacts current civil service reform by shaping the environment for change, potentially hindering the identification and promotion of reform-minded individuals, and perpetuating a culture that prioritizes superficial allegiance over performance. The previous Barisan Nasional (BN) administration's focus on loyalty at the ballot box, rather than on merit or performance, created a system where advancement was often tied to displays of allegiance to ministers or Umno officials. This historical context suggests that ingrained practices and attitudes within the civil service may resist the fundamental shifts required for effective reform.
Emphasis on Superficial Allegiance Over Performance

Under the previous Barisan Nasional (BN) government, the primary concern regarding civil servants was their loyalty at the ballot box, with an expectation that their family members would also vote for the ruling coalition. Consequently, career progression within the civil service was frequently contingent on outward displays of loyalty to BN ministers or Umno officials, rather than on actual performance or efficiency in their roles. This created a culture where "sucking up" and superficial window dressing were more valuable for advancement than substantive contributions.
Undue Influence and Required Displays of Support

The influence of this loyalty-based system is exemplified by cases such as that of ex-treasury secretary-general Irwan Serigar Abdullah, who was implicated in using his position to support the former regime. Furthermore, civil servants were sometimes compelled to attend ministry events to demonstrate overt support for the minister and, by extension, the government of the day. Such practices established a precedent where political alignment was a key factor in professional standing, potentially overshadowing meritocratic principles.
Challenges in Identifying and Empowering Reform Talent

The current reform efforts face the challenge of identifying and empowering individuals who were previously sidelined due to a lack of overt political loyalty under the previous government. The ingrained culture that rewarded allegiance rather than performance may mean that those who were previously marginalized are now being sought to drive change. However, the extent to which these individuals can effectively lead reform, and whether those who benefited from the old system remain in positions of influence and resist change, remains a critical question for the success of current initiatives.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

How does past government loyalty affect current civil service reform?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends