How does the definition of legitimacy impact citizenship claims in Malaysia?

Question

Accepted Answer

Legitimacy's Impact on Malaysian Citizenship Claims

The determination of legitimacy, particularly concerning children born out of wedlock, significantly impacts their ability to claim Malaysian citizenship. In cases where parents are not married at the time of a child's birth, the High Court has ruled that such children are considered "illegitimate" and, under current interpretations of the Federal Constitution, can only inherit the citizenship of their non-Malaysian mother, not their Malaysian father. This legal interpretation creates substantial barriers for children born in Malaysia to a Malaysian father and a foreign mother, even if they are demonstrably stateless in their mother's country of origin.
Children Born Out of Wedlock Face Citizenship Rejection

In five distinct cases, children born in Malaysia to Malaysian fathers and non-Malaysian mothers, where the parents were not married at the time of birth, have been denied Malaysian citizenship. These children had repeatedly applied for citizenship under Article 15A of the Federal Constitution, a provision granting the government discretionary power to register individuals under 21 as citizens. However, these applications were consistently rejected, leading the affected individuals to pursue legal avenues to be recognised as Malaysian citizens. The High Court's reasoning in these cases hinges on the classification of these children as "illegitimate," asserting that they cannot derive citizenship from their Malaysian fathers under such circumstances.
Court Ruling on Inherited Citizenship for Illegitimate Children

The High Court's stance is that children born outside of a legal marriage are fundamentally distinguished from those born within marriage. Consequently, the court determined that these "illegitimate" children can only follow the citizenship status of their non-Malaysian mothers. This ruling disregards the potential for these children to be stateless, even when embassies of their mothers' countries have confirmed they do not hold citizenship there. The implication is that the legal status of the parents' union at the time of birth is paramount, superseding other factors like birth location or the father's Malaysian nationality.
Statelessness Carries Profound Life Difficulties

The consequences of being stateless and lacking Malaysian citizenship are severe and far-reaching. Individuals without citizenship face significant obstacles in various aspects of life, including the inability to obtain a driving licence, open bank accounts, secure loans, or engage in property ownership and insurance. Court documents in some of these cases highlight further challenges such as increased costs for medical treatment in public facilities, difficulties in pursuing higher education, and considerable uncertainty regarding future employment prospects. These challenges can also have a negative impact on subsequent generations, perpetuating a cycle of disadvantage.
Velmurugan's Case Highlights Parental Citizenship Discrepancy

The situation of Velmurugan, a 38-year-old stateless individual born in Malaysia, further illustrates the complexities. Velmurugan claims he and his late mother, Balamah, should be recognised as Malaysian citizens because they were born in Malaysia and hold no other nationality. His mother, born in Kuala Lumpur before Malaysia's independence in 1957, had her citizenship status recorded as undetermined by the National Registration Department (NRD) due to testimonial inconsistencies, despite DNA evidence confirming familial ties. While Velmurugan's mother's siblings born before Merdeka were registered as Malaysians, Velmurugan's own bid to be declared a Malaysian citizen was dismissed by the High Court, which stipulated he must first prove his mother's Malaysian citizenship. This requirement underscores the principle that a child's claim to citizenship can be contingent on their parent's status, particularly in cases where the parent's nationality is itself undetermined or contested.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

How does the definition of legitimacy impact citizenship claims in Malaysia?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends