Is current legislation enough to curb rising bullying cases in Malaysia?

Question

Accepted Answer

Current Legislation Is Insufficient to Curb Rising Bullying Cases in Malaysia

The Ministry of Education (MoE) has reported a significant increase in bullying incidents, with 4,994 cases recorded since October 2023, compared to 3,887 in 2022 and 326 in 2021. Despite the MoE's implementation of guidelines for managing bullying and sexual harassment, experts argue that the existing legal framework is inadequate to deter perpetrators. The absence of a specific anti-bullying law and the limitations of current provisions, such as the Minor Offences Act, are seen as key reasons for the persistent rise in these cases.
Lack of Specific Legal Deterrents

Malaysia currently lacks a dedicated law specifically addressing bullying. Instead, existing provisions are scattered, primarily under the Minor Offences Act 1955. Experts, such as Mimi Sintia Mohd Bajury, a senior lecturer at UiTM's Faculty of Law, describe this approach as "piecemeal," indicating that it does not offer sufficient punitive measures to create a significant deterrent effect on potential bullies. This legal vacuum means that perpetrators may not perceive bullying as a serious offence, contributing to its continued prevalence.
Inadequate Penalties for Verbal Bullying

A significant deficiency identified by experts is the leniency of penalties for certain forms of bullying. Dr Mohamad Naqiuddin Dahamat Azam, an associate researcher at UPM, highlighted that the maximum fine of RM100 for verbal bullying under the Minor Offences Act 1955 is disproportionately low when weighed against the profound emotional and psychological suffering experienced by victims. This lack of commensurate punishment fails to reflect the severity of the harm inflicted, potentially encouraging a disregard for the impact of such actions.
Impact on Victims Necessitates Stronger Legislation

Bullying has severe consequences for victims, extending beyond physical harm to encompass significant emotional distress. Experts note that victims often suffer from severe stress, depression, a decline in self-confidence, and, in the most tragic instances, suicidal ideation. The current legal framework's inability to effectively address and punish these harmful behaviours means that the psychological and emotional toll on victims is not adequately acknowledged or remedied, underscoring the need for more robust legal measures.
International Precedents for Specific Anti-Bullying Laws

Several countries have successfully implemented specific legislation to combat bullying, offering Malaysia potential models for reform. Nations like the United States and the Philippines have enacted dedicated bullying acts that provide a clearer legal framework and more appropriate sanctions for offenders. Adopting similar comprehensive legislation could equip Malaysia with more effective tools to manage and reduce bullying incidents, ensuring greater protection for students and individuals affected by such behaviour.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Is current legislation enough to curb rising bullying cases in Malaysia?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends