Is it appropriate for Perlis Mufti to criticise the PM?

Question

Accepted Answer

The Appropriateness of a Mufti Criticising the Prime Minister is Debated

The Umno Veterans Association has stated that Perlis Mufti Datuk Mohd Asri Zainul Abidin should not engage in political commentary while serving as a religious adviser. The association's secretary, Datuk Mustapha Yaakub, expressed that Mohd Asri had exceeded his professional boundaries by criticising Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak's leadership. The association considers Mohd Asri's actions and perceived support for the Opposition as unacceptable and beyond tolerance.
Official Roles and Responsibilities of a Mufti

In Malaysia, a Mufti serves as a state-level Islamic religious dignitary responsible for issuing fatwas and providing religious guidance. Their role is primarily to advise the government and the Muslim community on matters of Islamic law and practice. While the position demands adherence to Islamic principles, the scope of public engagement, particularly on political issues, is often a subject of interpretation and debate. General guidelines within the Malaysian Islamic framework suggest that religious figures should offer constructive counsel with decorum, rather than directly participating in partisan politics or criticising leadership in a manner perceived as undermining.
Concerns Regarding Political Meddling

Datuk Mustapha Yaakub of the Umno Veterans Association explicitly stated that Mohd Asri had overstepped his job scope and responsibilities as a mufti. The association views Mohd Asri's criticisms and alleged support for the Opposition as a form of political meddling that could tarnish the dignity of religious institutions. They suggested that if Mohd Asri wished to enter politics, he should resign from his mufti position and contest in elections, even proposing he could run on an Opposition ticket.
Broader Context of Religious Figures in Politics

Mohd Asri is noted as one of the more outspoken muftis in Malaysia, known for expressing his views even when they diverge from established norms or official stances. This reputation highlights a broader tension in Malaysia regarding the public role of religious scholars. While religious figures are respected for their knowledge, the extent to which they can engage in public discourse, especially on political matters, is a sensitive issue. The Umno Veterans Association's stance reflects a segment of opinion that seeks to maintain a clear separation between religious advisory roles and active political participation.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Is it appropriate for Perlis Mufti to criticise the PM?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends