Is the RM100,000 fine adequate for severe environmental pollution?

Question

Accepted Answer

The Adequacy of a RM100,000 Fine for Severe Environmental Pollution Remains a Point of Contention for Victims

Victims of the Sungai Kim Kim pollution incident have voiced strong concerns that the maximum RM100,000 fine imposed on a lorry driver for illegal waste disposal is insufficient, particularly when weighed against the long-term suffering and health consequences they continue to endure. These sentiments arise as the penalties levied, including a RM320,000 total fine for P Tech Resources Sdn Bhd across eight charges, are viewed by those affected as not adequately reflecting the severity of the environmental damage and its human toll.
Long-Term Health Impacts Persist Years Later

The environmental catastrophe at Sungai Kim Kim in March 2019, which involved the illegal dumping of toxic waste and led to the closure of 111 schools affecting over 2,000 individuals, continues to have profound effects on victims. For instance, 16-year-old Irfan Wafiy Idham Wazir, who was diagnosed with Myokymia following the incident, still requires crutches and ongoing maintenance therapy five years later. Similarly, 11-year-old Nur Akma Darisha Sofea continues to experience respiratory issues and fluctuating health, necessitating ongoing pulmonologist treatment and impacting her school attendance.
Calls for Reassessment of Environmental Penalties

Victims and their families are advocating for a reassessment of environmental laws and penalties in Malaysia, arguing that current fines do not sufficiently deter future offences or compensate for the damages incurred. The argument is that a "meagre fine" inadequately values the well-being of affected children and communities, suggesting that penalties should more closely align with the gravity of the environmental crime and its lasting repercussions.
Legal Framework and Sentencing Considerations

The penalties were handed down by the Johor Baru Sessions Court on November 30, with the lorry driver receiving the maximum RM100,000 fine for illegal disposal of scheduled waste into Sungai Kim Kim. P Tech Resources Sdn Bhd was fined RM40,000 for each of its eight charges under the Environmental Quality (Clean Air) Regulations 2014, accumulating to RM320,000. While the Department of Environment (DoE) has been acknowledged for its role in ensuring accountability, the scale of these fines in comparison to the extensive human and ecological damage remains a significant point of discussion.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Is the RM100,000 fine adequate for severe environmental pollution?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends