Should enforcement authorities use excessive force when arresting transgenders?

Question

Accepted Answer

Enforcement Authorities Should Not Use Excessive Force When Arresting Transgenders

Lawyer Aidil Khalid has stated that enforcement authorities should refrain from abusing their power or employing excessive force, even when undertaking the arrest of transgender individuals. This perspective emerged from discussions regarding the motivations behind LGBT advocates' strong push to decriminalise the status of the transgender community. Supporters articulated that their primary concern stems from instances where enforcement officers allegedly misuse their authority and resort to excessive force during arrests. Khalid acknowledged that regardless of the perceived wrongdoing of the transgender community, authorities must not overlook their own mistakes.
Abuse of Power by Enforcement Officers

Aidil Khalid highlighted that a significant reason cited by LGBT supporters for seeking legal changes is the alleged abuse of power and use of excessive force by enforcement officers during arrests. He acknowledged that while the actions of the LGBT community might be considered wrong, it is imperative for enforcement bodies to conduct themselves appropriately and avoid misconduct. A 2014 Human Rights Watch report documented serious allegations against Malaysian religious authorities, including stripping transgender women naked, sexual molestation, physical assault, extortion for money and sexual favours, and public humiliation.
Challenges Faced by the Transgender Community in Malaysia

The transgender community in Muslim-majority Malaysia continues to grapple with substantial stigma and persecution. Shariah laws in the country classify cross-dressing as a religious offence, contributing to the challenges faced by transgender individuals. Associate professor Irwan Mohd Subri noted that some imams refuse to permit transgender individuals from attending congregational prayers at local mosques. He also shared that many transgender individuals, referred to by the community as 'mak nyah', express a desire to deepen their understanding of Islam and draw closer to Allah, yet they have frequently experienced humiliation from religious figures, including ustaz and imams.
Recommended Approach for Engaging with the Transgender Community

Irwan Mohd Subri suggested that an effective approach to engaging with the transgender community for religious guidance should commence with empathy and understanding. He stressed the importance of first comprehending their needs and treating them with respect. Subri argued that it is difficult to offer assistance or guide individuals back into religious observance if their concerns are not understood and if they are turned away. This approach emphasizes a need for a more compassionate and inclusive method when interacting with transgender individuals seeking to connect with their faith.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Should enforcement authorities use excessive force when arresting transgenders?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends