Should EU antitrust veto of O2 UK bid be dismissed?

Question

Accepted Answer

Court Adviser Recommends Dismissal of General Court's Ruling on O2 UK Bid Antitrust Veto

An adviser to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has recommended that the General Court's ruling, which annulled the European Commission's antitrust veto on CK Hutchison Holdings Ltd's bid for O2 UK, should be dismissed. This recommendation suggests that the General Court's judgment should be set aside, and the case should be re-heard by the General Court for a fresh ruling. The European Commission had previously appealed the General Court's 2020 decision.
General Court's 2020 Ruling and Commission Appeal

In 2020, the General Court ruled that the European Commission had failed to prove that the proposed merger between CK Hutchison and O2 UK would harm competition or lead to increased prices. This judgment effectively raised the standard of proof required for the Commission to block mergers, which regulators argued imposed an extremely high burden on them. The European Commission subsequently appealed this decision.
Advocate-General's Recommendation on Burden of Proof

Advocate-General Juliane Kokott at the CJEU stated in her non-binding recommendation that there is no justification for demanding a higher standard of proof for concentrations that lead to non-coordinated effects on oligopolistic markets compared to those resulting in 'conglomerate' or 'collective' type dominant positions. This points to a potential issue with the General Court's assessment of the evidence presented by the Commission.
Significance for Telecom Mergers

The case, formally known as C-376/20 P Commission v CK Telecoms UK Investments, is being closely monitored by telecommunications companies across Europe. These companies have been advocating for the EU to relax its merger rules for the sector, particularly for transactions that reduce the number of market players from four to three. The outcome of this case could have significant implications for future consolidation within the European telecom industry.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Should EU antitrust veto of O2 UK bid be dismissed?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends