Should Muslim women have freedom in choosing to wear the hijab?

Question

Accepted Answer

Muslim Women's Freedom in Choosing to Wear the Hijab

The question of whether Muslim women should have the freedom to choose whether or not to wear the hijab is a complex one, with interpretations of religious texts and scholarly opinions playing a significant role. While some groups, like Sisters in Islam, advocate for individual choice citing the principle of "no compulsion in religion," the prevailing view within Islamic jurisprudence, supported by Quranic verses and scholarly consensus, posits that wearing the hijab is a religious obligation. However, there is a distinction drawn between the headscarf and more extensive veiling, such as the niqab, where interpretations vary more widely.
The Religious Obligation of Hijab

The Holy Quran instructs both men and women to dress modestly. For women, this generally entails covering the entire body except for the face, hands, and feet when in the presence of non-related men. Specific verses, such as Al-Ahzab: 59 and An-Nur: 31, are cited to support this obligation, referring to drawing cloaks over bodies and head-coverings over bosoms. Scholars widely agree that the hijab, encompassing the head, chest, neck, and ears, is a clear commandment from Allah, akin to daily prayers and fasting.
Distinctions in Veiling Practices

While the obligation of covering the head and body is generally accepted, there exists a dispute among scholars regarding the compulsory nature of covering the face, or wearing the niqab. The majority view is that the face is not considered aurat (parts of the body that must be covered), and therefore, covering it is not compulsory. This stance has been reflected in legal contexts, such as a Malaysian court case, Hjh Halimatussaadiah bte Hj Kamaruddin v. Public Services Commission, which ruled that wearing the niqab is not a religious obligation and not an integral part of Islam.
Principles of Islamic Dress Code

Beyond the extent of coverage, Islamic dress code for women also emphasizes looseness, thickness, and non-transparency to conceal the body's shape. The attire should not attract undue attention to a woman's beauty, nor should it be ostentatious or resemble male or non-believer costumes. While these requirements provide a framework for Islamic compliance, the specific choice of fabric, fashion, and style remains within the individual's discretion, as long as these fundamental standards are met.
Understanding "No Compulsion in Religion"

The principle of "no compulsion in religion," often cited in support of individual freedom, primarily refers to Islam's stance against forcing non-Muslims to convert. Once an individual embraces Islam, they are understood to be obliged to observe all its duties. Therefore, the argument that "no compulsion" allows selective adherence to religious obligations is generally considered a misinterpretation; embracing Islam entails a commitment to its entirety. Acts that hinder the manifestation of religious obligations, such as wearing the hijab, can thus be seen as a violation of freedom of religion.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Should Muslim women have freedom in choosing to wear the hijab?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends