What are the legal hurdles to holding local council elections in Penang?

Question

Accepted Answer

Legal Obstacles Prevent Local Council Elections in Penang

The Penang state government has exhausted its legal avenues in its pursuit of holding local council elections, encountering significant legal hurdles that have thus far prevented their implementation. Despite legislative efforts at the state level, including the passage of a motion and the drafting of an enactment, the apex court's decision has affirmed the existing limitations. The state government's appeal to the Federal Court for a judicial pronouncement on its motion was ultimately unsuccessful, marking the conclusion of its legal challenges.
State Legislative Actions and Federal Court Ruling

The Penang state government had undertaken concrete steps towards establishing local council elections. This included passing a motion within the State Legislative Assembly and subsequently drafting a specific enactment to facilitate these elections. As a final resort, the state government sought a judicial pronouncement from the Federal Court to validate its motion. However, the Federal Court ruled against the state government's appeal, effectively ending its legal recourse on this matter.
The Absence of Local Council Elections in Malaysia

Historically, Malaysia has not held direct elections for local councillors since the suspension of local government elections in 1965. This absence is largely rooted in the legal framework established by federal legislation, which governs the structure and administration of local authorities. While the Penang state government has expressed a desire for greater democratic participation through local elections, the prevailing legal landscape at the federal level has presented a significant barrier.
Federal Jurisdiction and Future Efforts

The matter of local council elections falls under federal jurisdiction, as indicated by Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow's statement that the state government has done all it could. While the state government has reached the end of its legal efforts, the pursuit of this objective has been delegated to the Minister of Housing and Local Government, Zuraida Kamaruddin. This suggests that any future progress would require action and potential legislative changes at the federal level, as local council elections are not currently part of the ruling coalition's manifesto.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

What are the legal hurdles to holding local council elections in Penang?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends