What are the hidden risks of hiring academics solely on PhDs and publications?

Question

Accepted Answer

Hidden risks associated with hiring academics based solely on PhDs and publications

Hiring new academic staff in Malaysian universities, encompassing both public and private institutions, increasingly prioritizes candidates with PhDs and a strong publication record. While these criteria are often implemented as screening mechanisms by human resources, deans, or department heads, the exclusive reliance on them can present significant drawbacks, potentially overlooking effective educators and creating a disconnect between institutional priorities and student needs. The PhD requirement, a relatively recent stipulation by the Malaysian Qualifications Agency (MQA) implemented within the last two to three years, has become a near-universal prerequisite, even for candidates with substantial teaching experience, if their doctoral research is not directly aligned with the subject area.
Emphasis on academic credentials may sideline effective educators

A primary concern is that the stringent requirement for a PhD and a high H-index may exclude many highly capable lecturers and teachers. These individuals, despite potentially holding only a Master's degree or having a less extensive publication history, often possess exceptional communication skills, the ability to inspire students, and a deep dedication to their craft. Their effectiveness in the classroom and their capacity to foster a positive learning environment may be overlooked simply because they do not meet the specific academic or publication benchmarks, leading to a loss for both the educators and the students they could potentially serve.
International rankings drive publication demands, potentially at the expense of teaching quality

Private higher education institutions, in particular, have adopted publication requirements such as a high H-index as a strategy to improve their standing in international university rankings like QS and Times Higher Education. These rankings are closely watched as they can directly influence student enrollment numbers, especially from international markets, and have tangible financial implications. Consequently, the pursuit of higher rankings can inadvertently lead to an overemphasis on research output, potentially overshadowing the equally crucial aspect of effective teaching and student engagement.
Disconnect between academic metrics and teaching effectiveness

The focus on publication records can create a peculiar disconnect between what students require from their educators and what appears to enhance a university's appeal in rankings. Universities often need lecturers who can provide consistent support throughout the semester, demonstrate genuine care for student development, and actively participate in departmental activities. However, individuals who excel in these areas may not necessarily be prolific academic writers. The current hiring practices can lead to the rejection of such valuable staff members simply because they have not published extensively in academic journals, irrespective of their proven teaching abilities and commitment.
Certain disciplines are less suited to traditional publication metrics

Furthermore, in some fields, such as journalism, video production, teaching, and graphic design, the traditional academic publication metric may not be a reliable indicator of excellence. These are often practitioner-oriented disciplines where individuals who are highly skilled and actively engaged in their professional practice may lack the time or inclination to produce the lengthy, formatted manuscripts typically required by top-tier academic journals. The insistence on such publications can therefore misrepresent the caliber of professionals in these fields and create an unnecessary barrier to entry for talented individuals.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

What are the hidden risks of hiring academics solely on PhDs and publications?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

2

0

0

Share with friends