What criteria does Article 15A use to grant citizenship, and why is it often rejected?

Question

Accepted Answer

Article 15A Citizenship Applications and Rejection Factors

Article 15A of the Federal Constitution grants the Malaysian government discretionary power to register individuals under the age of 21 as citizens. However, there is no automatic entitlement to citizenship under this provision, and applications can be rejected without the need for a stated reason. This lack of guaranteed success, coupled with the age limitation, often leads to difficulties for applicants.
Discretionary Power and Lack of Guaranteed Success

The Malaysian government holds the ultimate authority in deciding citizenship applications made under Article 15A. This means that fulfilling the basic eligibility criteria does not ensure approval. The law allows for applications to be denied without any formal explanation provided to the applicant, a situation that has been observed in cases where individuals have repeatedly sought citizenship.
Age Limit and Application Rejection Cycles

A significant challenge for applicants under Article 15A is the age ceiling. The provision is for individuals below 21 years of age. Many applicants face prolonged waiting periods for a decision on their applications. If a decision is delayed beyond their 21st birthday, they are no longer eligible to apply under Article 15A, effectively reducing their opportunities. This bureaucratic lag can be a critical factor in the eventual rejection of applications.
Challenges for Children of Unmarried Parents

Specific difficulties arise for children born to Malaysian fathers and non-Malaysian mothers when the parents were not married at the time of birth. These children are often classified as "illegitimate" under the law. Such individuals have frequently attempted to gain citizenship through Article 15A multiple times, only to face repeated rejections. The court system has also addressed these cases, with High Court rulings sometimes stating that these children would follow their non-Malaysian mother's citizenship, even if the children claim to be stateless.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

What criteria does Article 15A use to grant citizenship, and why is it often rejected?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends