What does Section 19B presume about mothers of exposed new born children?

Question

Accepted Answer

Section 19B Presumes Mothers of Exposed Newborns are Malaysian Permanent Residents

Section 19B of the Federal Constitution's Second Schedule, Part III, establishes a presumption that a newborn child found exposed or abandoned within Malaysia was born to a mother who is a permanent resident of Malaysia. This legal provision is designed to prevent statelessness among children born in Malaysia who are found abandoned, as it facilitates their eligibility for Malaysian citizenship. The presumption, when not successfully rebutted by the government, allows such children to be considered Malaysian citizens by operation of law, provided they meet other constitutional requirements for citizenship, such as those outlined in Article 14(1)(b) and Section 1(a) of the Second Schedule.
Application in Citizenship Cases

The presumption under Section 19B was a key factor in a recent Court of Appeal decision concerning a 17-year-old girl, identified as M, who was abandoned shortly after birth in Klang, Selangor. The court found that the facts presented demonstrated M was indeed a "new born child found exposed," thus triggering the presumption. The government failed to rebut this presumption by establishing the true identity and nationality of M's biological mother, nor did it prove she was not a permanent resident. Consequently, M was declared a Malaysian citizen by operation of law.
Distinction from Other Abandonment Cases

In contrast, the same Court of Appeal panel unanimously ruled against a 29-year-old woman, identified as G, who was abandoned as a child at approximately one year old in Pahang. The court determined that Section 19B did not apply to G's case because the evidence indicated she was not a "new born" child at the time she was found. While G was found abandoned and her biological parents remain unknown, the legal threshold of being a "new born" was not met, preventing the presumption of her mother being a permanent resident from being invoked.
Purpose of the Presumption

The intention behind Section 19B is to provide a pathway to citizenship for abandoned newborns in Malaysia. By presuming the mother is a permanent resident, the law ensures that these children, born within Malaysia, have a clear connection to the country through their presumed maternal parentage. This legal mechanism aims to address situations where biological parentage is unknown or unascertainable, thereby preventing children from becoming stateless and ensuring they can be integrated into Malaysian society.
Government's Burden of Proof

When Section 19B is invoked, the burden shifts to the government to disprove the presumption. This requires the authorities to establish the true identity and nationality of the biological mother, and to demonstrate that she was not a permanent resident of Malaysia at the time of the child's birth. Failure to meet this burden of proof means the presumption stands, and the child is typically recognised as a Malaysian citizen under the relevant constitutional provisions.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

What does Section 19B presume about mothers of exposed new born children?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends