What does the soil tradition reveal about societal attitudes in Kolkata?

Question

Accepted Answer

The Soil Tradition Exposes Kolkata's Societal Hypocrisy Towards Sex Workers

The tradition of collecting soil from outside brothels for Durga Puja rituals in Kolkata reveals a deeply ingrained societal hypocrisy. While the soil is considered sacred and imbued with special qualities due to its association with sexual encounters, the sex workers themselves are ostracised and disrespected. This paradox highlights how society desires an element linked to sex work for religious purposes but simultaneously shuns and demeans the individuals who facilitate it.
The Sacred Soil and the Shunned Workers

Devotees believe that men leave behind all that is good before entering a brothel, rendering the doorstep soil holy and suitable for Hindu rituals, particularly the creation of Durga idols or for an "earth bath" for statues. This practice, deeply embedded in traditions surrounding the Durga Puja festival, imbues the very ground outside these establishments with ritualistic significance. However, this reverence for the soil starkly contrasts with the societal attitude towards the sex workers, who are often viewed with disgust and are not included in the festivities, despite their indirect contribution to the sacred element.
A Reflection of Discrimination

Sex workers in Kolkata's red light districts, such as Salima and Pushpa, articulate their anger and frustration over this tradition, viewing it as a direct manifestation of societal discrimination. They point out the glaring disconnect between their perceived value for their soil and their devaluation as human beings. The men who collect the soil for religious purposes often fail to acknowledge the sex workers' humanity, leading to feelings of being desired for a ritualistic component but disregarded as individuals.
Ritualistic Use Versus Social Ostracisation

The annual collection of this specific soil for the prominent Durga Puja festival underscores a societal paradox. The soil, considered essential for certain aspects of the religious ceremony, is derived from a space occupied by women who are themselves often shunned, looked down upon, and denied basic social recognition. This practice perpetuates a cycle where the "product" of sex work is venerated, while the providers are simultaneously marginalized and subjected to societal contempt, demonstrating a clear double standard in how different aspects of human interaction are perceived and treated.
Evolving Collection Methods Amidst Enduring Attitudes

In recent times, urban development, including increased concrete and tarmac, has presented challenges to the traditional methods of soil collection. To circumvent these difficulties, sex workers have sometimes sourced soil from the Ganges River and kept it outside their homes, facilitating its collection for religious use. This adaptation, however, does not alter the underlying societal attitudes. Despite the ritualistic importance of the soil and the purported role of sex workers as "social workers" as suggested by some cultural proponents, the sex workers remain excluded from celebrations and continue to face challenging conditions and societal judgment.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

What does the soil tradition reveal about societal attitudes in Kolkata?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends