What does the Zakir Naik controversy reveal about religious tolerance in Malaysia?

Question

Accepted Answer

The Zakir Naik controversy highlights significant double standards and hypocrisy regarding religious tolerance and freedom of speech within Malaysia's Malay Muslim community.

The cancellation of Islamic scholar Zakir Naik's talk at Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia (UTeM) on April 17, initially scheduled to explore "Similarities between Hinduism and Islam," triggered a strong reaction. While the cancellation stemmed from unease within the Hindu community and a statement from the Inspector-General of Police, it subsequently led to an uproar among some Malay Muslims. This segment of the community perceived the cancellation as an infringement on freedom of speech and suggested that Hindus feared mass conversions, conflating this specific event with broader entry bans faced by Naik in other countries like the UK and Canada.
Perceived Infringement on Freedom of Speech

The controversy surrounding Zakir Naik's cancelled talk at UTeM revealed a segment of the Malay Muslim community that champions freedom of speech when it aligns with their interests, such as when criticisms are directed at other religions or when an Islamic scholar presents views that resonate with their own beliefs. However, this same group often objects when Islam is criticized or when an Islamic scholar like Naik faces restrictions. This selective application of the principle of free speech was evident in the immediate outcry following the talk's cancellation, with many viewing it as an attack on their rights, despite the event being a single instance among Naik's scheduled engagements.
Contradictory Stances on Religious Discourse and Tolerance

The incident brought to light inconsistencies in how certain Malay Muslims approach religious discourse and tolerance. The article questions why individuals like Dr. Ulil Abshar Abdalla, who was denied entry in 2014 for allegedly being "deviant," were treated differently from Zakir Naik, who has been associated with supporting controversial figures like Osama Bin Laden. Furthermore, the article points to a contradiction in the application of religious freedom principles, where it is used to justify the propagation of Islam and defend converts, yet similar legal rights for individuals seeking to change their religion, such as Lina Joy, or outcries over international cases like Raif Badawi, are met with silence or opposition.
Double Standards in Inter-Religious Respect

A notable aspect highlighted by the Zakir Naik controversy is the double standard concerning respect for other religions. While some Malay Muslims express outrage over the mistreatment of Muslim minorities abroad and advocate for peaceful coexistence, a disconnect emerges when addressing local incidents. The article questions the absence of similar strong reactions when protests occur against the construction of Hindu temples or when places of worship for other faiths, such as a church, face attacks or are pressured to remove religious symbols. This suggests a selective application of the principle of respecting other religions, often dependent on the context and perceived threat to Islamic interests.
Selective Application of "Takfir" and Internal Dissent

The controversy also exposed a selective approach to internal religious dissent within the Malay Muslim community. While some rallied behind Zakir Naik's stance against the excommunication of Muslims, the article notes a tendency for the same individuals to readily label those with unorthodox opinions as "kafir" (infidel). This pattern was observed when progressive Muslims or organizations like Sisters In Islam faced accusations of being "deviant." The article posits that instead of actively opposing such instances of takfir (excommunication of another Muslim), many participate in the bandwagoning, indicating that internal tolerance is often contingent on adherence to specific, often narrow, viewpoints.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

What does the Zakir Naik controversy reveal about religious tolerance in Malaysia?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends