What insensitive remark did the PAS leader make?

Question

Accepted Answer

PAS Leader's Insensitive Remark Regarding Indonesian Band's Tsunami Tragedy

A PAS leader, Ahmad Dusuki Abdul Rani, the deputy chief of the Selangor PAS Ulama wing, faced widespread criticism for a video he posted that featured the Indonesian band Seventeen performing shortly before their stage collapsed during the Sunda Strait tsunami. In his commentary accompanying the video, he suggested that individuals should abstain from sinful activities, stating that "it courts suffering," thereby implying the band members' deaths were a consequence of their perceived vices. This remark, made in the context of a natural disaster that claimed over 150 lives and injured 600 others, was widely viewed as insensitive and disrespectful to the victims and their families.
Commentary Linking Vice to Tsunami Victims' Deaths

Ahmad Dusuki Abdul Rani posted a video showcasing the Indonesian band Seventeen during their performance, which was tragically interrupted by the Sunda Strait tsunami. His accompanying remarks focused on the concept of "vice" and "suffering," suggesting a causal link between the two. This perspective was presented without acknowledging the unpredictable and devastating nature of the tsunami itself, which struck popular beaches on southern Sumatra and the western tip of Java without warning.
Attempt to Solicit Donations Amidst Criticism

In addition to his commentary on the tragedy, Ahmad Dusuki also included details for three bank accounts, requesting donations for his tahfiz school. This act of soliciting funds in direct connection with the insensitive remarks about the deceased musicians drew further condemnation. Users questioned the appropriateness of leveraging a disaster and the deaths of musicians for fundraising purposes, with some accusing him of seeking popularity.
Public Condemnation and Questions of Faith

The Instagram post garnered over 41,000 views and more than 1,000 comments, with a significant portion expressing outrage. Users questioned the cleric's understanding of faith and his approach to proselytizing, or "dakwah." Many pointed out the tragic circumstances of the band's demise, including the loss of band members and their families, and contrasted this with the leader's focus on sin and fundraising. Some commenters highlighted that the event was a natural disaster, suggesting that any group performing at the time would have faced the same fate.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

What insensitive remark did the PAS leader make?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends