What is the core defence of MediaRakyat in the defamation suit?

Question

Accepted Answer

MediaRakyat's Defence in Defamation Suit Centers on Press Freedom and Reporting Duties

MediaRakyat's primary defence in the defamation suit filed by Datuk Seri Najib Razak and Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor is that the news portal was merely fulfilling its duty by uploading a recording of a public figure's speech. The portal contends that the lawsuit infringes upon press freedom, arguing that any grievances regarding the content of a statement should be directed at the original speaker, not the entity that recorded or disseminated it. As a demonstration of its commitment to fair reporting, MediaRakyat has offered Najib free airtime to respond to the allegations through its platforms.
Defence Based on Fulfilling Reporting Duties

The portal owner, Chan Chee Kong, asserts that MediaRakyat was simply carrying out its function by broadcasting a speech delivered by PKR leader Rafizi Ramli. The lawsuit, filed by Najib and Rosmah, concerns alleged defamatory remarks made by Rafizi during a forum in November, which MediaRakyat subsequently uploaded. Chan maintains that it is unfair to penalise MediaRakyat for reporting or streaming comments made by a public figure.
Argument for Press Freedom Infringement

MediaRakyat argues that being sued for disseminating a recording of a speech constitutes an infringement on the freedom of the press in Malaysia. Chan stated that the portal is committed to enhancing freedom of information within the country, suggesting that the lawsuit undermines this principle. He further posited that a functioning democracy relies on the existence of a free press.
Proposed Resolution of Offering Rebuttal Airtime

In an effort to uphold principles of fair news dissemination, MediaRakyat has offered Najib the opportunity to utilise its online channels for a response. This offer of free airtime aims to provide a platform for the Prime Minister to address any concerns or allegations raised in the speech that was uploaded by the portal.
Context of the Defamation Claim

The legal action taken by Najib and Rosmah stems from remarks made by Rafizi Ramli during a forum discussing the government's decision to remove oil subsidies. During his speech, Rafizi reportedly criticised the government's policy and included a comment about Rosmah. MediaRakyat's video of this speech was published online with a title related to the defence of fuel subsidies.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

What is the core defence of MediaRakyat in the defamation suit?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends