What led to the substantial increase in damages for the refugee?

Question

Accepted Answer

Court of Appeal Significantly Increased Damages for Refugee Due to Future General Damages Award

The substantial increase in damages awarded to Henry Siang Len, a Myanmar refugee, from RM734,000 to RM1,685,594 was primarily driven by the Court of Appeal's decision to grant a significant sum for future general damages. This additional award, amounting to RM951,514, was made by Justice Kamardin Hashim, fundamentally altering the financial compensation for the irreversible brain damage Siang Len sustained.
Award of Future General Damages

Justice Kamardin Hashim's inclusion of RM951,514 for future general damages represented a critical shift in the assessment of Siang Len's ongoing needs. This category of damages typically accounts for future pain and suffering, loss of amenities, and the long-term impact on quality of life, which are substantial given Siang Len's current minimally conscious state and dependence on others for daily activities. The High Court had previously dismissed claims for future general damages, making this appellate decision a pivotal factor in the increased total.
Increased High Court Costs and Special Damages

Beyond the future general damages, the Court of Appeal also revised the costs awarded. The High Court costs were elevated to RM159,730 from an initial RM50,000. While the High Court had previously awarded RM234,000 in special damages, which cover quantifiable financial losses, the main driver for the overall surge in the award was the new provision for future general damages.
Original Lawsuit and Medical Negligence

The original lawsuit was initiated in 2016 by Siang Len, through his litigation representative Dr Caroline Gunn, against Hospital Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (HUKM) and two doctors. The case stemmed from severe and irreversible brain damage suffered by Siang Len in 2010, following a massive overdose of Ketamine, administered at five times the intended dosage, during treatment for injuries sustained from an assault.
Impact of Medical Error

The overdose occurred while Siang Len was seeking treatment at HUKM for injuries including a fractured mandible, sustained the night before he was due to resettle in the United States. The medical error led to Siang Len's current condition, where he remains in a minimally conscious state and requires constant care, necessitating a comprehensive re-evaluation of the damages to reflect the lifelong consequences of the incident.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

What led to the substantial increase in damages for the refugee?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends