What leverage does Russia hold in the Snowden standoff?

Question

Accepted Answer

Russia's Leverage in the Snowden Standoff

Russia holds significant leverage in the Edward Snowden standoff primarily through its control over his physical location and its capacity to influence his departure from Russian territory. While Snowden remains in the transit area of Sheremetyevo Airport, Russian authorities maintain he has not formally entered the country, a stance that circumvents direct legal obligations regarding extradition requests. President Vladimir Putin has explicitly stated he will not extradite Snowden, a position that underscores Russia's refusal to comply with US demands. This control over Snowden's immediate fate, coupled with the protracted nature of asylum decisions from countries like Ecuador, places Russia in a position to dictate the pace and terms of any resolution.
Control Over Snowden's Physical Location

Edward Snowden's continued presence in the transit area of Sheremetyevo Airport in Moscow is a key factor in Russia's leverage. Russian authorities have consistently stated that Snowden has not formally entered Russia, thereby positioning him as someone within their jurisdiction but not under their sovereign immigration laws. This technicality allows Russia to manage his presence without immediately acceding to US extradition requests, which President Putin has stated he will not fulfill. The duration of his stay in this liminal space, with no immediate confirmed onward travel arrangements, places the onus on other nations and the United States to negotiate his eventual departure or disposition.
Diplomatic and Propaganda Potential

Russia appears to be leveraging the situation for diplomatic and propaganda advantage, particularly in its ongoing discourse with the United States regarding human rights and surveillance. By highlighting disclosures of US government surveillance programs, such as those collecting data from major internet companies like Google and Facebook, Russia can frame itself as a defender of privacy against perceived American overreach. The upper house of the Russian parliament has even announced plans to investigate whether US intelligence agencies violated the rights of Russians through such data collection, directly tying Snowden's revelations to a domestic inquiry. This strategy allows Moscow to criticize US policies and potentially bolster its own international standing by contrasting its actions with those of Washington.
Strategic Position in US-Russia Relations

The Snowden standoff occurs within a broader context of strained US-Russia relations, which Russia can exploit. The two nations have previously clashed over issues such as human rights, Russia's treatment of political opponents, and the conflict in Syria. In this environment, Russia's decision to allow Snowden to remain in its territory, while publicly denying any direct involvement in aiding him, serves as a point of friction that can be used to Russia's advantage. President Putin's dismissal of US accusations as "ravings and rubbish" further signals Russia's unwillingness to be dictated to by Washington, reinforcing its independent foreign policy stance on the global stage.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

What leverage does Russia hold in the Snowden standoff?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends