What specific parts of the Selangor fatwa were declared invalid by the Federal Court?

Question

Accepted Answer

Federal Court Declares Sections of Selangor Fatwa Invalid

The Federal Court has declared specific portions of the Selangor fatwa issued in 2014 invalid, significantly altering its applicability. The court ruled that the second and third paragraphs of the fatwa are no longer valid. Additionally, the court determined that the part of the first paragraph referring to SIS Forum, organisations, and institutions is also invalid. However, the fourth paragraph of the Selangor fatwa remains valid.
Invalidity of Second and Third Paragraphs

The second and third paragraphs of the Selangor fatwa have been declared invalid by the Federal Court. The second paragraph had called for the banning and seizure of publications containing elements of liberalism and religious pluralism. The third paragraph instructed the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC) to block social websites that contravened Islamic teachings and hukum syarak. The Federal Court's decision on these paragraphs stems from the finding that Selangor did not possess the constitutional authority to issue directives involving federal agencies and their powers.
Partial Invalidity of the First Paragraph

The first paragraph of the fatwa, which initially labelled SIS Forum (Malaysia) and any individual, organisation, or institution adhering to "liberalism and religious pluralism" as "deviants" from Islamic teachings, has been partially invalidated. The Federal Court's ruling specified that this paragraph remains valid only in its reference to individuals. Consequently, the declarations of deviance pertaining to SIS Forum, as well as other organisations and institutions, are no longer legally effective. This distinction arises from the Federal Constitution's State List, Item 1, which grants powers for fatwas to be issued on actual human beings professing Islam, not artificial legal persons like companies, organisations, or institutions.
Continued Validity of the Fourth Paragraph

The fourth paragraph of the Selangor fatwa has been upheld as valid by the Federal Court. This paragraph states that any individuals holding onto liberalism and religious pluralism should repent and return to Islam. The court's affirmation of this paragraph is consistent with its interpretation that the state's Islamic authorities have the exclusive jurisdiction to address matters concerning individuals professing the religion of Islam, aligning with their scope of powers under the Federal Constitution.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

What specific parts of the Selangor fatwa were declared invalid by the Federal Court?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends