Why are calls for caning in schools resurfacing in Malaysia?

Question

Accepted Answer

Calls for Caning in Malaysian Schools Resurface Following Recent Violent Incidents

Recent acts of extreme violence within Malaysian schools have triggered renewed public discourse and demands for the reintroduction of caning as a disciplinary measure. These calls are frequently articulated as a means to reinstate "respect" and order, often framed through notions of tradition and discipline.
Escalating Incidents Spur Public Outcry

The resurfacing of calls for caning is directly linked to a series of disturbing violent incidents that have occurred in Malaysian educational institutions. These include the killing of a 16-year-old student in Selangor by a peer, the gang rape of a female student in Melaka where the assault was recorded and shared online, and the death of a 13-year-old in Sabah attributed to bullying. These events have understandably generated significant public outrage and a sense of urgency to address perceived breakdowns in school discipline and safety.
Historical and Cultural Context of Corporal Punishment

The arguments advocating for caning often invoke "tradition" and "discipline" as justifications for its use. While these calls may seem like a simple desire to return to established practices, they are rooted in a historical context where corporal punishment was prevalent. Such methods, often seen as a legacy of colonial-era punitive systems, equate pain with control and obedience. The persistence of these ideas suggests a deeper societal engagement with the concept of physical punishment as a primary tool for moral instruction and behavioural modification.
The Debate Over Caning as an Educational Tool

Proponents of caning often believe it is an effective method to curb misconduct and restore order, viewing it as a necessary deterrent. This perspective frequently frames the act as a form of discipline that instills respect and accountability. However, research in criminology and psychology suggests that while caning may temporarily suppress behaviour due to fear of pain, it does not foster genuine understanding or moral reasoning in students. Instead, it can lead to negative psychological outcomes and perpetuate cycles of violence.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why are calls for caning in schools resurfacing in Malaysia?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends