Why are children of Malaysian fathers and foreign mothers denied citizenship based on marital status?

Question

Accepted Answer

Children of Malaysian fathers and foreign mothers are denied citizenship because the law is applied to treat them as having the foreign mother’s nationality when they are born outside a marriage.

In the Court of Appeal cases discussed, the government’s position is that children born to a Malaysian father and a non-Malaysian mother who were not married at the time of birth are treated as “illegitimate” or “born outside of a marriage”. The government argues that Malaysian citizenship is not automatically conferred merely because the father held a Malaysian passport, and that the child may instead take the mother’s nationality under the mother’s country’s rules, such as Thai citizenship in Haritharan’s case.
The government’s approach links “born outside a marriage” to the mother’s nationality
The cases centre on children whose Malaysian fathers and foreign mothers were not married when the child was born, including Haritharan Mugunthan, born in April 2001 in Hospital Besar Ipoh with a Malaysian father and Thai mother. The government’s stance is that these children should follow the non-Malaysian mother’s nationality rather than the Malaysian father’s, explicitly framing the children as “illegitimate” or born outside a marriage.
A Malaysian passport is treated as not equal to citizenship
Haritharan said he was issued a Malaysian passport in June 2002 when he was just over a year old, but later discovered in 2009 that his birth certificate states he is not a Malaysian citizen. Senior federal counsel Shahidah Nafisah Leman argued that a passport issued earlier does not prove citizenship, and that the Federal Constitution does not require a passport for someone to be automatically a Malaysian.
The citizenship question becomes whether the child is already a citizen of the mother’s country
The hearing focused on whether the children had already taken up the mother’s nationality when born to a foreign mother, as reflected in the government’s argument that Haritharan would have Thai citizenship based on Thailand’s laws. Lawyer Larissa Ann Louis argued that the government failed to provide conclusive proof that the children had become citizens of their birth mothers’ countries, pointing to certificates from the Indonesian and Philippines embassies in Malaysia showing they were not registered and not recognised as citizens there.
Proof disputes play out in court, including what counts as an “effort to register”
Larissa said the children were essentially treated as stateless and that the government should prove they had taken up foreign citizenship, not the children who have limited resources. The government countered that embassy documents were not enough to show a child had made an effort to register—for example, Nurhafizza Azizan said one document only showed child J was not registered as an Indonesian citizen, without showing she tried to register herself.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why are children of Malaysian fathers and foreign mothers denied citizenship based on marital status?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends