Why are illegal land clearings in Penang downplayed by the state?

Question

Accepted Answer

State Government Downplays Illegal Land Clearing as "Small Scale" Despite Audit Findings

The Penang state government has characterized illegal land clearing activities as "small scale," even as a national audit revealed a significant number of privately owned plots being worked on without approval. This official stance contrasts with findings by the Auditor-General, which highlighted weaknesses in the state's administrative oversight and enforcement mechanisms concerning land development. The report detailed instances of earthworks, land excavation, and slope cutting conducted without necessary council approval and without considering Environmental Impact Assessment requirements.
Audit Reveals Widespread Unapproved Land Works

A national audit identified 268 privately owned land parcels that had been subject to unapproved activity since 2012. The third series of the 2014 Auditor-General's Report specifically noted the construction of 11 illegal structures on hill slopes across various locations in Penang, including hotels and chalets. Furthermore, the audit uncovered that several restaurants operating in Balik Pulau lacked proper business licenses, indicating a broader pattern of regulatory non-compliance.
State Attributes Activities to Farming and Small Housing

State committee chairman Chow Kon Yeow explained that the cleared privately owned land was primarily utilized by farmers for agricultural purposes and the construction of small residential structures. Over the past four years, the local council detected more than 200 such cases, with many offenders receiving summonses and being mandated to replant trees on the affected land. Chow maintained that these were predominantly minor operations, involving clearing for planting, access roads, and modest housing, rather than large-scale development projects.
Enforcement Weaknesses and Limited Penalties Cited

The Auditor-General's report identified systemic weaknesses in the state government's approach to managing land clearing issues. These included insufficient surveying, lax enforcement, and a lack of inter-agency coordination, which contributed to the prevalence of illegal activities, particularly in water catchment areas. For instance, out of 31 reported illegal land-clearing incidents in a single year, only five resulted in fines, with many cases either pending or not yet brought to court. Chow acknowledged that the current legal framework grants limited powers to the local council, characterized by low fines that offenders often disregard. This, coupled with the council's failure to consistently monitor and patrol after issuing stop-work orders, has allowed the problem to persist, increasing the risk of soil erosion, landslides, and mudslides.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why are illegal land clearings in Penang downplayed by the state?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends