Why are private member motions typically placed lower on the Dewan Rakyat agenda?

Question

Accepted Answer

Private Member Motions Are Placed Lower on the Dewan Rakyat Agenda Because They Do Not Represent the Government

Private member motions are typically listed at the bottom of the Dewan Rakyat order paper because they are initiated by individual members of Parliament and do not reflect the government's official business. According to Rule 15 (1) and (2) of the Standing Orders, government business is given precedence and is scheduled according to the government's considerations. However, a private motion can be brought forward earlier if a minister moves it, as permitted by Rule 14 (2) of the Standing Orders.
Government Business Takes Precedence

The Standing Orders of the Dewan Rakyat, specifically Rules 15 (1) and (2), stipulate that government business must be prioritised over all other matters. This means that initiatives and proposals from the executive branch are scheduled and debated before private members' motions. The arrangement of government business is determined by the government's own priorities and considerations.
Private Motions Are Introduced by Individual MPs

Motions brought forth by private members, as opposed to the government, are not part of the official government agenda. These motions represent the views or proposals of individual MPs or groups of MPs and do not carry the weight of government endorsement. Consequently, they are placed lower on the order paper to reflect this distinction in their origin and official standing.
Ministers Can Advance Private Motions

While generally placed lower, there is a provision within the Standing Orders, specifically Rule 14 (2), that allows for a private motion to be brought forward. This exception occurs when a minister moves the motion, effectively giving it precedence. This mechanism has been observed, for instance, when a minister advanced the tabling of a private bill to allow it to be read, though such instances are noted as being difficult to achieve.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why are private member motions typically placed lower on the Dewan Rakyat agenda?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends