Why are telco shares underperforming despite increased internet use?

Question

Accepted Answer

Telco Shares Underperform Despite Increased Internet Use Due to High Costs, Debt, and Fixed Pricing Structures

Telecommunication companies' stock prices are lagging in global markets even as lockdowns worldwide drive a surge in internet usage and boost online sales for other businesses. This underperformance is largely attributed to a combination of significant fixed costs, existing debt burdens, and market disruption, which prevent telcos from fully capitalizing on the increased demand for their services. Unlike other defensive sectors that have maintained their value, the telecommunications sector has experienced notable declines.
Increased Demand Outstrips Monetization Opportunities

The surge in internet usage, driven by millions confined to their homes, has placed immense pressure on telco networks. While this increased demand necessitates substantial spending to maintain and upgrade infrastructure, the industry's fixed pricing structures limit the ability to generate additional revenue from this investment. Companies like 1&1 Drillisch AG have noted that flat-rate plans mean there is no immediate increase in revenue from customers spending more time online or on calls.
Erosion of Revenue Streams and Future Contract Concerns

Beyond the lack of direct monetization from increased usage, telcos are facing the evaporation of crucial revenue streams such as roaming fees, which have significantly diminished due to the drastic reduction in global travel. Furthermore, there is anticipation of a slowdown in new contract acquisitions as rising unemployment rates may impact consumers' and businesses' ability to afford telecommunications services. This dual pressure on existing and future revenue is a key factor contributing to investor concern.
Dividend Pressure and Financial Obligations

Investor confidence is further eroded by concerns over dividends, which have been under pressure for several years. Telecommunication companies often carry substantial debt and have ongoing capital expenditures, particularly for investments like 5G technology. Consequently, any decline in cash flow prioritizes servicing these financial obligations to bondholders, potentially impacting dividend payouts. Companies such as AT&T Inc, Telefonica SA, and Vodafone Group PLC have all experienced notable stock declines, with Vodafone reporting a 50 per cent surge in data traffic but still seeing its stock fall.
Market Dynamics Favoring Content Providers

While network operators struggle, the companies whose content and services rely on this infrastructure, such as Netflix Inc and Amazon.com Inc, have generally outperformed. This disparity highlights a market dynamic where the providers of digital services are seen as benefiting more directly from increased internet consumption than the underlying network providers themselves. Reports from Moody's Investors Service have also indicated heightened risks for some operators, such as Digicel Group, regarding their ability to meet bond obligations.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why are telco shares underperforming despite increased internet use?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends