Why are the mother and children being deported if they are Malaysian citizens?

Question

Accepted Answer

Mother and Children Facing Deportation Despite Claimed Malaysian Citizenship

The mother and her children are reportedly facing deportation due to the Immigration Department's decision not to renew their temporary papers, a move that the writer contends is arbitrary and deprives them of their fundamental right to a nationality. This action is questioned as potentially rendering them stateless, despite the mother being born to parents who were Permanent Residents in Malaysia, a status that should entitle her and her children to Malaysian citizenship. The writer further questions the Home Minister's decision to deport them to Indonesia, arguing they would become stateless there despite being rightful Malaysian citizens.
Alleged Entitlement to Citizenship

The article asserts that the mother is entitled to Malaysian citizenship because she was born to parents who held Permanent Resident status in Malaysia. Consequently, her children are also considered entitled to the nation's citizenship. This claim suggests a basis for their right to nationality within Malaysia, stemming from their parentage and birth within the country.
Refusal to Renew Temporary Papers

A key factor leading to their predicament is the Immigration Department's registration department's decision to cease the renewal of the family's temporary papers. This action is described as arbitrary and a deliberate act to strip them of their inherent right to a nationality. The refusal to renew these papers appears to be the immediate trigger for their potential deportation.
Concerns Over Statelessness and Discrimination

The writer raises serious concerns that the mother and children may have been rendered stateless due to discrimination or as an exercise of power by authorities. The act of deporting individuals who claim to be citizens, especially to a country where they would also be stateless, is highlighted as a violation of international conventions, specifically the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) and the UN Sustainable Development Goal 2030 (SDG2030), to which Malaysia is a party.
Questioning the Home Minister's Decision

The Home Minister is directly questioned regarding the decision to send the family to Indonesia. The argument presented is that this action would result in them becoming stateless, which contradicts their claimed status as rightful Malaysian citizens. This implies that the deportation order is being made without due consideration for their citizenship claims and the potential humanitarian consequences.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why are the mother and children being deported if they are Malaysian citizens?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends