Why did BAM approve Lee Zii Jia but not Goh Jin Wei?

Question

Accepted Answer

BAM's Approval of Lee Zii Jia Over Goh Jin Wei Remains Unclear

The Badminton Association of Malaysia (BAM) approved the request of Lee Zii Jia, the world No 7 and All-England champion, to turn professional. This decision came after both Lee Zii Jia and Goh Jin Wei were banned a week prior for resigning from BAM. While Lee Zii Jia's request was granted, Goh Jin Wei's was initially not, raising questions about the consistency of BAM's decisions.
Inconsistent Treatment of Players

BAM banned both Lee Zii Jia and Goh Jin Wei upon their resignation from the national team. The association cited its role in nurturing these players, providing training, coaches, tournament expenses, and stipends as reasons for its stance against premature departures. However, historical precedents indicate that not all players who leave BAM are banned. Notable examples include Chan Peng Soon and Goh Liu Ying, who resigned in December 2018 without repercussions, followed by Goh V Shem and Tan Wee Kiong in January 2019, who also left BAM without punishment. Furthermore, the Sidek brothers famously left BAM in the 1980s to form Nusa Mahsuri, the first professional badminton club in Malaysia, without facing any ban.
Potential Influence of Appeals and Institutional Safeguarding

The article suggests that Lee Zii Jia's resignation was approved, potentially due to an appeal he submitted, while Goh Jin Wei's was not. Those who support BAM's strict approach argue that such measures are necessary to safeguard the institution and deter other players from leaving. They often refer to past instances where players who left were banned as precedents. However, this argument overlooks instances where players have departed BAM without facing any punitive actions.
Broader Implications for Malaysian Badminton

The decision-making process regarding player departures raises concerns about BAM's approach to managing its talent. The article posits that BAM should facilitate the transition of its players to professional status if they wish to pursue it, rather than imposing bans. The reasoning provided is that successful professional players continue to represent and win for Malaysia, regardless of their affiliation with BAM. Ultimately, the article implies that the focus should be on winning for the nation, which is a larger objective than the interests of BAM itself, and that Goh Jin Wei's ban should also be revoked without requiring an appeal.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why did BAM approve Lee Zii Jia but not Goh Jin Wei?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends