Why did Giakoumakis win MLS Newcomer of the Year over Messi?

Question

Accepted Answer

Giakoumakis Clinches MLS Newcomer of the Year Award Over Messi Due to Broader Support Across Voting Blocs

Giorgos Giakoumakis secured the MLS Newcomer of the Year award, surpassing Lionel Messi, primarily due to stronger backing from club staffers and media, despite Messi winning the vote among MLS players. The award acknowledges the most impactful player making their MLS debut in the 2023 regular season with prior professional experience. Giakoumakis's consistent performance throughout the season for Atlanta United, culminating in a team-high 17 goals, resonated more broadly with the voting bodies than Messi's mid-season arrival and impact.
Media and Club Staffers Favoured Giakoumakis

The voting results reveal a significant divergence in preferences between different constituent groups. Media representatives overwhelmingly selected Giakoumakis, awarding him 56.65% of their votes, a stark contrast to Messi's 12.14%. Similarly, club technical staffers also leaned towards the Atlanta United forward, giving him 46.34% of their votes compared to Messi's 34.15%. This dual endorsement from media and club personnel was instrumental in Giakoumakis's victory.
Messi Led Player Votes but Fell Short Overall

While Lionel Messi garnered the highest percentage of votes from his fellow MLS players at 35.54%, this support was not enough to offset the preferences of the other voting groups. Giakoumakis followed closely among players with 34.34% of the vote. This indicates that while the playing body recognised Messi's influence, the collective decisions of those involved in club operations and media coverage ultimately determined the award's recipient.
Giakoumakis's Season-Long Contribution Highlighted

The award criteria emphasize impact from a player who made their MLS debut during the 2023 regular season and possessed prior professional experience. Giakoumakis, having joined Atlanta United earlier in the season, consistently contributed to his team's performance, scoring 17 goals. This sustained presence and goal-scoring record throughout the campaign likely played a crucial role in his recognition by media and club staffers.
Atlanta United Secures Consecutive Newcomer Award

Giakoumakis's win marks the second consecutive year an Atlanta United player has received the MLS Newcomer of the Year award. This follows Thiago Almada's recognition in 2022, highlighting a pattern of impactful newcomers for the club. This consecutive achievement underscores Atlanta United's success in acquiring and integrating players who quickly make a significant mark on the league.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why did Giakoumakis win MLS Newcomer of the Year over Messi?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends