Why did NZ PM prioritise trade over human rights in China visit?

Question

Accepted Answer

New Zealand Prime Minister Prioritised Trade Over Human Rights in China Visit Due to Domestic Political and Economic Considerations

New Zealand Prime Minister Chris Hipkins prioritised trade and economic opportunities over contentious issues such as human rights abuses in Xinjiang or security concerns during his recent visit to China. This strategic approach is largely driven by domestic political and economic pressures, with the country facing a likely tight election in three months and already experiencing a recession. Hipkins aims to project an image of strong economic stewardship to voters, necessitating a harmonious relationship with China, New Zealand's largest trading partner, to protect vital export markets.
Focus on Economic Recovery Amidst Election Year

With the New Zealand economy in recession and an election looming, Hipkins's primary objective appears to be assuring the electorate that the Labour party can restore prosperity. This necessitates avoiding any disputes with China that could jeopardise New Zealand's exports, which are crucial for economic recovery. The visit was framed as an opportunity to strengthen trade ties and explore economic opportunities, a message designed to resonate with voters concerned about their financial well-being.
Strategic Positioning and Leadership Profile

Hipkins is also using the visit to establish his leadership profile and demonstrate his capability to govern the country for another term. By focusing on pragmatic economic engagement, he seeks to step out of the shadow of former Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and present himself as a capable leader focused on tangible benefits for New Zealand. This approach aims to secure a mandate for continued leadership by showcasing his ability to manage the nation's most significant bilateral relationship effectively.
Historical Context of New Zealand's China Relations

Historically, New Zealand has been perceived as more conciliatory towards China within the Five Eyes security alliance, which includes Australia, the United States, Britain, and Canada. While previous administrations, including former PM Ardern and current Foreign Minister Nanaia Mahuta, have raised concerns about issues like Xinjiang, Hong Kong, the Pacific, and the Taiwan Strait, Hipkins's recent visit marked a shift in emphasis. The joint statement following his meeting with President Xi Jinping notably omitted any mention of these sensitive topics.
Analyst Perspectives on Pragmatic Diplomacy

Analysts suggest that Hipkins's cautious approach is a calculated political manoeuvre. Professor Robert Ayson of Victoria University noted that Hipkins "pulled his punches on anything controversial," indicating a deliberate strategy to avoid alienating China. This pragmatic diplomacy is seen as a way to gain international legitimacy for Beijing while securing economic benefits for New Zealand exporters, with a delegation of 29 businesses accompanying the Prime Minister. David Capie, Director of the Centre for Strategic Studies at Victoria University, believes Hipkins "wants to be seen as a sort of good steward of the China relationship" in this election year.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why did NZ PM prioritise trade over human rights in China visit?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends