Why did the court doubt the authenticity of the 2011 exclusive management contract?

Question

Accepted Answer

The Court Doubted the Authenticity of the 2011 Exclusive Management Contract Due to Evidence of Creation and Suspicious Timing

The Hong Kong High Court expressed significant doubts regarding the authenticity of the 2011 exclusive management contract presented by former agent Samuel Yu. The court found it highly probable that the contract was fabricated by Yu's younger brother, with its creation appearing to coincide with an investigation by Hong Kong's Inland Revenue Department into a HK$40 million payment made by Asia Entertainment Group (AEG) to actress Cecilia Cheung in July 2011.
Evidence Suggests the Contract Was Created by the Agent's Brother

The judgment indicated that the purported 2011 exclusive management contract was likely "created" by Samuel Yu's younger brother. This finding cast serious doubt on the legitimacy of the document, suggesting it was not a genuine reflection of an agreement entered into by Cheung.
Suspicious Timing Linked to Tax Investigation

The court noted that the creation of the contract appeared to be closely timed with an investigation by Hong Kong's Inland Revenue Department. This investigation, concerning a HK$40 million payment made by AEG to Cheung in July 2011, raised concerns that the contract might have been produced to influence or mislead tax authorities.
Agent's Testimony Deemed Incredible and Inconsistent

Furthermore, the presiding judge, Mr Justice Herbert Au-yeung Ho-wing, described Samuel Yu as an "incredible" witness. The judge found Yu to be evasive and his evidence to be internally inconsistent, undermining his credibility and the validity of the claims based on the disputed contract. The judgment also highlighted Yu's poor business ethics, noting his willingness to forge documents to mislead tax authorities.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why did the court doubt the authenticity of the 2011 exclusive management contract?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

2

0

0

Share with friends