Why do ex-generals deem Gibran unfit to lead?

Question

Accepted Answer

Retired Generals Deem Indonesian Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka Unfit to Lead Due to Alleged Constitutional Violations and Ethical Breaches

A group of retired Indonesian military generals has formally petitioned for the impeachment of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka. The petition asserts that Gibran is unfit to lead, citing alleged constitutional violations, ethical breaches, and questions surrounding his qualifications. The generals specifically pointed to the controversial Constitutional Court ruling that lowered the age requirement for presidential and vice-presidential candidates, a decision they claim paved the way for Gibran's candidacy. This ruling was authored by Anwar Usman, President Joko Widodo’s brother-in-law, who subsequently faced dismissal for judicial ethics violations.
Allegations of Constitutional and Ethical Infringements

The petition submitted by the Forum Purnawirawan Prajurit TNI to the House of Representatives and the People’s Consultative Assembly outlines several key concerns. Central to their argument is the assertion that Gibran's path to the vice presidency was facilitated by a flawed judicial process. They highlight the Constitutional Court's decision to alter the age limit, which they view as a direct contravention of constitutional principles. Furthermore, the generals expressed skepticism regarding Gibran's ethical conduct, referencing his alleged association with an anonymous online account that disseminated derogatory material.
Doubts Regarding Competency and Experience

Beyond constitutional and ethical considerations, the retired generals have raised concerns about Gibran's perceived lack of competency and experience for national leadership. The petition specifically references his relatively short tenure of two years as the mayor of Surakarta, questioning whether this experience adequately prepared him for the complexities of governing Indonesia. The group's letter explicitly states that in his six months as vice president, Gibran has "shown no capacity to assist the President," labelling him a "burden" and "unqualified to lead" a nation of Indonesia's complexity.
Securing Support and Procedural Considerations

The petition's submission was preceded by a meeting with former vice president Try Sutrisno, who reportedly gave his endorsement for the impeachment initiative. This meeting, confirmed by group secretary Bimo Satrio, suggests a strategic approach to advancing their cause. While the call for impeachment is noted as legally valid, political analyst Dedi Kurnia Syah points out that such proceedings face substantial procedural obstacles. He emphasizes that impeachment cannot proceed solely on political grounds without clear and demonstrable legal justification, indicating the high threshold required for such action.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why do ex-generals deem Gibran unfit to lead?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends