Why do national value initiatives like Wawasan 2020 falter?

Question

Accepted Answer

National Value Initiatives Like Wawasan 2020 Falter Due to Divergent Malaysian Values

National value initiatives, such as Wawasan 2020, often falter because they attempt to prescribe a singular set of collective values for a nation like Malaysia, where a significant divergence in core values, aspirations, and mental models exists among its populace. This inherent diversity leads to a lack of consensus on what constitutes national success or failure, rendering top-down value prescriptions largely ineffective.
Wawasan 2020's Goal and Challenges

Wawasan 2020, launched in 1991, outlined nine strategic challenges that Malaysia aimed to overcome by 2020, encompassing the creation of a united Malaysian nation, a mature, democratic society, and a fully moral and ethical society. The vision prescribed a set of values and characteristics that Malaysians should attain to achieve these ambitious goals. However, the inherent difficulty lay in imposing a uniform value system on a population with deeply ingrained, often opposing, beliefs and perspectives.
Divergent Values Undermining Collective Aspirations

The fundamental reason for the faltering of such initiatives is the existence of diametrically opposed values within Malaysian society. For instance, concepts like unity are contrasted with discord, maturity with immaturity, democracy with authoritarianism, and morality with immorality. This spectrum of opposing values, such as liberal versus illiberal, tolerant versus intolerant, and progressive versus conservative, means that there is no definitive agreement on which values are universally "good" or "bad" for the nation. Consequently, efforts to identify and implement a singular set of collective values that all Malaysians aspire to become an exercise in futility.
Historical Precedents of Value Initiatives

Malaysia has a history of attempting to establish national collective values. Prior initiatives, such as the Rukunegara in 1970, Islam Hadhari (Civilisational Islam) under Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi, and 1Malaysia under Prime Minister Najib Razak, all aimed to foster a shared sense of national identity and values. However, the persistent challenges and the continued observation of societal discord suggest that these efforts, like Wawasan 2020, have struggled to bridge the fundamental differences in values held by various segments of the Malaysian population.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why do national value initiatives like Wawasan 2020 falter?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends