Why does India remain dependent on cash despite digital growth?

Question

Accepted Answer

India's Persistent Cash Dependency Despite Digital Growth

India's transition to digital payments faces significant hurdles, with cash remaining deeply entrenched in the economy despite substantial growth in digital transactions and a large user base for internet and mobile phones. This continued reliance on physical currency is driven by a combination of infrastructural limitations, economic incentives, and social factors that outweigh the benefits of digital alternatives for a considerable portion of the population.
Rural Infrastructure and Accessibility Gaps

The lack of essential facilities in rural areas remains a primary driver of cash dependency. For instance, a farmer from Satara district highlighted the issue of non-operational ATMs in his village, forcing him to travel 32 kilometers to the nearest town for cash withdrawals. This scarcity of accessible banking infrastructure means that cash is not just a preference but a necessity for daily transactions, including purchasing agricultural inputs like fertilisers, and for managing potential family emergencies. The higher operating costs associated with establishing and maintaining ATMs have led to a slowdown in new installations, exacerbating cash hoarding tendencies.
Economic Incentives for Cash Transactions

The implementation of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in mid-2017 has inadvertently incentivised cash usage. Buyers and sellers, particularly in sectors like gold and silver, opt for cash transactions to avoid the additional tax burden. A Mumbai-based jeweller noted that many small vendors sell gold without issuing receipts, a practice welcomed by consumers who can thus circumvent the 3% GST. Furthermore, increased import taxes on gold have boosted the profitability of smuggled gold, which is often traded in cash by smaller jewellers at a discount. Retailers also sometimes pass on additional charges to customers for electronic transactions to offset service partner fees, making cash a more economical option for consumers and small businesses alike.
Financial Literacy and Behavioral Factors

Beyond infrastructure and economic policies, financial illiteracy presents a significant barrier to digital adoption, especially in rural and informal sectors. This lack of understanding of digital financial tools limits the migration to electronic payments. Anecdotal evidence, supported by a LocalCircles survey, indicates that a substantial percentage of individuals, around 27% in one survey, paid for 50-100% of their purchases over a 12-month period without receiving a receipt. This suggests a preference for informal transactions, often facilitated by cash, and a potential avoidance of the formal tax system. While digital payment systems have seen growth, with transaction values rising by 19.5% in 2018/19 and 22.2% in 2017/18, these gains have not fully displaced cash for a significant segment of the Indian populace.
The Enduring Role of Currency in Circulation

The 2016 demonetisation policy, which aimed to curb black money and promote a digital economy by invalidating 86% of currency in circulation, has not achieved its long-term goal of reducing cash dependency. Instead, currency in circulation has seen a significant increase, growing 17% to 21.1 trillion rupees by March 2019. The ratio of currency in circulation to GDP also rose to 11.23% by March 2019, up from 8.69% in March 2017. This indicates that despite policy interventions and the expansion of digital payment infrastructure by the Reserve Bank of India, the fundamental drivers of cash usage—including accessibility, perceived cost savings, and established habits—continue to maintain its prominence in the Indian economy.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why does India remain dependent on cash despite digital growth?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends