Why does Johor BN leadership call election debates unnecessary?

Question

Accepted Answer

Johor BN Leadership Views Election Debates as Unnecessary and Counterproductive

The leadership of Johor Barisan Nasional (BN), exemplified by state chief Onn Hafiz, considers public election debates to be unnecessary and counterproductive. This stance stems from a belief that such debates, when held outside the formal setting of the state assembly, tend to be confrontational and unhealthy for political discourse. Instead, they favour a more controlled environment for political discussion.
Preference for Formal Assembly Discourse

Onn Hafiz specifically stated that dignified discussions should be confined to the state assembly. He expressed this view in response to an invitation for a debate from Maszlee Malik, a former education minister and candidate. This suggests a preference for established legislative chambers as the appropriate venue for political engagement, rather than public forums like markets or television.
Perceived Confrontational Nature of Debates

A core reason cited for the opposition to public debates is their perceived confrontational nature when conducted outside the state assembly. This perspective implies a discomfort with the direct clash of ideas and arguments that often characterises public electoral debates. The argument is that politics inherently involves the confrontation of ideas, values, and ideologies.
Desire to Avoid Scrutiny and Uncertainty

The underlying sentiment appears to be a reluctance among certain political leaders and coalitions to be subjected to direct public scrutiny and examination. This includes avoiding situations where they might be questioned on specific issues, such as the state's response to floods or its economic development model. The preference is for leaders to make declarations rather than engage in real-time responses to opponents, as this allows them to avoid potential embarrassment or appearing unprepared. The author suggests that leaders like Onn Hafiz prefer to "declare" rather than be "examined or questioned," indicating a desire for a more predictable and less challenging electoral process.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why does Johor BN leadership call election debates unnecessary?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends