Why have some residents bristled at official descriptions of their old neighbourhoods?

Question

Accepted Answer

Residents Disagree with Official Portrayals of Jeddah Neighbourhoods Marked for Redevelopment

Some residents affected by Jeddah's massive redevelopment project have expressed strong disagreement with official characterisations of their former neighbourhoods as undesirable areas rife with drugs and crime. These residents have also raised significant concerns regarding the compensation process, particularly the lack of clarity in valuing properties that have already been demolished. These sentiments highlight a disconnect between the government's narrative of urban renewal and the lived experiences of those displaced.
Disputed Official Descriptions

Authorities have promoted the extensive clearance and construction in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia's second-largest city, as a flagship initiative by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. This project aims to transform areas described as "slums" into modern amenities, including a stadium, an oceanarium, and an opera house. However, individuals who have lost their homes have challenged this framing, arguing that their neighbourhoods were not accurately represented as mere hotbeds of illicit activities. Many of these communities have housed a mix of Saudi nationals and expatriates for up to 60 years, suggesting a long-standing presence and established community life that contrasts with the official portrayal.
Concerns Over Compensation Mechanisms

Beyond the dispute over neighbourhood descriptions, a primary concern for displaced residents revolves around the compensation process. Earlier this year, residents voiced apprehension about the absence of a clear methodology for assessing the value of their destroyed properties. This uncertainty is compounded by a survey conducted by ALQST for Human Rights, which found that a portion of residents had not received adequate information on how to initiate compensation claims, or were not even aware that compensation was an option. The official Saudi Press Agency reported that the first batch of compensation, amounting to one billion Saudi riyals (approximately RM1.1 billion), has begun to be distributed, but details on the number of recipients or the timeline for future payouts remain unspecified. Appraisals are reportedly being conducted by "independent committees" representing four government agencies.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why have some residents bristled at official descriptions of their old neighbourhoods?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends